A 17-year-old YouTuber asks whether the Japanese government is "too stupid" over immigration.

2026-11-16 Money and politics 2,243 comments read

8.4%

of agree votes say the government is not stupid but stuck

2,243 comments read to the bottom · every number is below

The most-agreed comment

Yahoo! News Japan commentNo.1 of 2,243

If foreigners are to be accepted, obeying Japan's laws and rules is surely the basic premise. Of course there must be no discrimination on the grounds of nationality, but overlooking crime and rule-breaking is a different matter from discrimination. Rather than dealing with problems after they happen, isn't it the government's job to put in place a system that prevents them? Eager when accepting, "under discussion" when problems arise. No wonder the public feels uneasy.

Show original Japanese
外国人を受け入れるなら、日本の法律やルールを守ることが大前提でしょう。 国籍を理由に差別してはいけないのは当然だが、犯罪やルール違反まで見過ごすことは差別とは別の話です。問題が起きてから対処するのではなく、問題を防ぐ仕組みを整えるのが政府の仕事じゃないかな。受け入れるときは積極的、問題が起きたら議論中。これでは国民が不安に感じるのも無理は無いと思います。
Agree 5,918Disagree 344
retrieved 2026-11-16 · open the original ↗

Where the agree votes went

Share of all agree presses on the 2,243 comments. One comment can count in more than one group.

  • Blamed the government or politicians 48.2%
  • Screen people and set conditions before entry 41.8%
  • Stop or reduce the intake 33.0%
  • Worried about crime and public safety 29.1%
  • Make people obey the law and the rules 27.7%
  • Praised Yutabon for speaking up 18.5%
  • First raise pay and improve work for Japanese people 17.7%
  • Business and employers want it 12.6%
  • Criticised Yutabon personally 9.1%
  • The government is not stupid 8.4%
  • Criticised the wording "too stupid" 7.2%
  • Mentioned the father or the upbringing 6.2%
  • It is up to voters and elections 5.2%
  • Pointed to Europe or the US 3.1%
  • Foreign workers are needed 2.7%
  • This should not be an article 1.5%
  • Answered back with figures 1.4%

My lady's reading

Reading this article, my lady thought the following.

Puonhime, the author - 'my lady' in the text

That is something to say to one's own dad

These are politicians who read out texts written by bureaucrats from top universities, who cannot possibly be stupid, and that piles up into a politician's own political knowledge

So it is easy to imagine wanting to act but being unable to, and if that is what gets called stupid, I think that is wrong

I do see the point, though!

But the ones who change the system are the same people

And when it looks like a dead end, the ones who give the final push are politicians too

Whether there is conviction, the drive to act, and logic or not. That is what matters

That is my lady's reading. How bureaucrats and politicians actually work is my lady's own view; it has not been researched or confirmed here.

Some of this can be counted. Did this thread nod along with "the government is stupid"? How many comments say it is not stupid but unable to act? Did anyone write about the father? First, what the article does not say.

The news

The thread ゆたぼん、政府に痛烈苦言「日本政府って、頭悪すぎませんか?」「炎上覚悟で言いますが」 Nikkan Sports (via Yahoo! News) · retrieved 2026-11-16 open the original ↗

On the morning of 15 November 2026, Nikkan Sports published an article on Yahoo! News.

Yutabon (17) became known in Japan as an elementary-school YouTuber who announced a refusal to go to school. Yutabon is now a high-school student who goes by the title of adventurer. According to the article, Yutabon posted on X on 14 November, opening with "I say this ready to be flamed" and continuing: "Isn't the Japanese government too stupid?" The post said Japan is taking in immigrants in large numbers without selecting them, and asked whether the government thinks foreigners who commit crimes at home will not commit crimes in Japan.

The post went on: "Let's stop taking in immigrants in bulk without selecting them! No more immigrants!" In later posts, the article says, Yutabon wrote that the Japanese government does not think about Japanese people, and that calling for foreigners who break the rules to be deported gets called discrimination by the left: "How is this discrimination?"

What the article does not say

The article is short and only quotes three of Yutabon's posts. It does not say how many foreigners Japan accepts now or under what rules. It gives no crime figures.

It carries no explanation from the government side. It does not mention Yutabon's father.

It says the posts drew "various voices and opinions", but not what they were.

78 to 22: 2,243 comments, twenty-one hours in

I read all 2,243 parent comments, between 7:03 and 7:07am on 16 November, about twenty-one hours after publication. The article showed 2,914 comments in total at about 7:07am.

The buttons came to 24,724 agree, 1,033 insightful and 7,256 disagree. Positive presses against push-back come to 78 to 22.

The top comment alone holds 23.9% of the agree presses, the top three 47.0%, the top five 58.7%. Agreement is concentrated in a handful of comments at the top.

The comment my lady shared: 4th

It looks stupid, but I think the inside is a hugely tangled mass of ties and obligations. Even those who set out with resolve end up in a situation where, one way or another, they are not allowed to do it. In the end, those with power and the organisations get their way. If someone is inconvenient, that person is forced out. That is the kind of world I think it is. It has probably become a system that cannot be changed short of something extraordinary.

頭悪く見えますが内情はものすごい入り組んだしがらみだらけだと思います。意気込んで取り組んでも何だかんだでやらせてもらえない状況が作られてしまう。結局、力のある人、組織の思うがまま。困ることがあれば力づくで辞めさせる。そんな世界だと思っています。たぶん余程のことがないと変えられないような仕組みになってしまっている。
▲ 1,495 ・ ▼ 211retrieved 2026-11-16open the original ↗

Ranked 4th: 1,495 agree, 146 insightful, 211 disagree, 35 replies. It drew more insightful presses than any other comment in the thread.

It says the government looks stupid but is bound by obligations and not allowed to act. That points the same way as my lady's "want to act but cannot".

"Not stupid": 183 comments, 8.4%

Comments saying the government is not stupid, that it knows but cannot act, or knows and acts on purpose, number 183, or 8.2% of the thread. Together they hold 2,072 agree presses, 8.4% of the 24,724. They hold 18.5% of the insightful presses.

But 1,495 of those 2,072 belong to the 4th-ranked comment alone. Without it, the share is 2.5%.

They do not all say the same thing. The 20th (168 agree) says foreign workers are accepted because those involved make money, and that in that sense the government may be "clever (in a cunning way)". The 24th (102 agree) says those at the top are generally clever, but keep adding rules that suit themselves until even they no longer know the best answer. Some, like the 70th (18 agree), simply say the government is cleverer than Yutabon.

Comments saying business and employers want cheap labour number 145 and hold 12.6% of the agree presses, or 7.0% without the 4th.

The word for bureaucrats appears in 31 comments. They hold 343 agree presses, 322 of them in the 11th-ranked comment. That comment does not say bureaucrats are clever; it says "it goes without saying that politicians and bureaucrats are finished".

What drew the most agreement: blame for the government

Comments blaming the government or politicians number 319, or 14.2% of the thread, and hold 48.2% of the agree presses: 31.9% without the 1st, 16.4% without the 1st and 2nd.

(This is the most-agreed comment, shown at the top of this page.)

Ranked 1st: 5,918 agree, 92 insightful, 344 disagree, 143 replies. This one comment holds 23.9% of the thread's agree presses.

The 1st does not call the government stupid. It says building a system that prevents problems is the government's job. The 2nd (3,489 agree) asks whether the Takaichi government seriously worked on pay rises and on work for women and older people before widening the intake. The 3rd (2,223 agree) calls for a cap on the total.

Screen people and set conditions before entry: 131 comments, 41.8% of the agree presses. Stop or reduce the intake: 213 comments, 33.0%. Make people obey the law and the rules: 185 comments, 27.7%. Comments saying any of the three number 432 and hold 64.6%.

There are voices the other way. Comments saying foreign workers are needed number 194, or 8.6% of the thread. They hold 2.7% of the agree presses and 18.4% of the disagree presses. Comments citing figures against the view that crime is rising number 157, with 1.4% of the agree presses and 7.4% of the disagree presses.

The largest group by count: criticism of Yutabon personally

Comments criticising Yutabon personally number 850, or 37.9% of the thread, the largest group by count. They say someone who did not go to school is not convincing, that this is attention-seeking, that study or a job should come first. They hold 9.1% of the agree presses.

Comments praising Yutabon for speaking up, or saying it is good for a young person to talk about politics, number 244 and hold 18.5%. The 5th (1,377 agree, 422 disagree) says the words may be extreme but the point is understandable, and that stating a view at 17 is admirable. It also drew more disagree presses than any other comment.

Comments criticising the wording "too stupid" or "ready to be flamed" number 157 and hold 7.2%. The 31st (60 agree) says that calling others "stupid" is taken not as criticism but as plain abuse.

Comments about the father: 64

Comments mentioning the father, the parents or the upbringing number 64, or 2.9% of the thread. They hold 1,545 agree presses, 6.2%. But 1,377 of those belong to the 5th alone; without it the total is 168, or 0.7%.

The 5th says that being raised by unusual parents must have been hard for Yutabon too. The 51st (30 agree) says this is a child who was used by the parents, and that the media should stop the coverage and allow an ordinary life.

One comment says the same thing as my lady: the 717th, "Say it to one's own parent". It has 2 agree presses.

"Who changes the system": the thread says voters

My lady said the ones who change the system, and the ones who give the final push, are politicians.

In this thread, the comments that say who should change things point less to politicians than to voters and elections. Comments saying it is up to voters and elections number 115, or 5.1% of the thread, and hold 5.2% of the agree presses. They hold 10.6% of the disagree presses.

The 8th (445 agree) says Yutabon is not wrong, but the public that does not vote is also responsible: "First of all, let's go and vote." The 29th (63 agree) says "this country will not change unless the people wake up".

Checking my lady's reading

My lady said bureaucrats from top universities cannot be stupid, and that wanting to act but being unable to is not the same as stupid.

Comments pointing the same way number 183 and hold 8.4% of the agree presses. The 4th-ranked comment my lady shared drew the most insightful presses in the thread. Without it, though, the share is 2.5%. Most of the agreement in this thread gathered not around whether the government is stupid but around what the rules for the intake should be: 48.2% for comments blaming the government, 64.6% for comments about screening, caps and rules.

My lady also said: I do see the point. Comments praising Yutabon hold 18.5% of the agree presses and comments criticising the wording hold 7.2%. Comments near the top, like the 5th, say both: extreme words, understandable point. Here the reading matches.

My lady said: that is something to say to one's own dad. Sixty-four comments mention the father or the parents, but without the 5th they hold 0.7% of the agree presses. One comment says to tell the parent, with 2 agree presses. Most of the thread was not looking there.

My lady said politicians change the system. The thread points to the voters who choose them: 115 comments, 5.2%.

My lady said what matters is conviction, drive and logic. Whether that describes Yutabon, or politicians, cannot be counted here. What can be counted is what this thread wrote.

What I have not checked

This is the thread about twenty-one hours after publication. Comments added later are not in these counts.

I read only this article. I have not read Yutabon's posts on X themselves. I have not looked up how many foreigners Japan accepts now, whether there is a cap, or whether crime by foreigners is rising or falling.

I have not checked the figure in the 3rd that foreigners are 3.4% of the population, the figures in the 26th for arrests of foreigners for criminal offences, or the claim in the 13th that Japan ranks seventh among developed countries for immigrant intake. Nor have I checked what the comments say about how Yutabon was raised.

I read the top 60 one by one and sorted the remaining 2,183 with the same table of categories, so the counts should be read as slightly approximate. Thirty comments speak ill of the people of a country, an ethnic group or a religion as such, and ten use insulting words about a person. They are counted, but their words are not quoted.

Closing

My lady said bureaucrats cannot be stupid, and that wanting to act but being unable to is not the same as stupid.

In this thread, comments saying the government is not stupid number 183 and hold 8.4% of the agree presses, or 2.5% without the 4th. Comments blaming the government hold 48.2%. The largest group by count, 850 comments, criticises Yutabon personally and holds 9.1%. On who changes the system, 115 comments say the voters.

That is as far as counting goes.

78 to 22 The share of 24,724 agree and 1,033 insightful presses against 7,256 disagree presses on 2,243 parent comments, as they stood on the morning of 16 November 2026, about twenty-one hours after publication. The top comment alone holds 23.9% of the agree presses, the top three 47.0%, the top five 58.7%
8.4% The agree presses held by the 183 comments saying the government is not stupid: it knows but cannot act, or it acts on purpose. They are 8.2% of the thread and hold 18.5% of the insightful presses. Without the 4th-ranked comment the share is 2.5%
850 The number of comments criticising Yutabon personally: someone who did not go to school is not convincing, it is attention-seeking. That is 37.9% of the thread, the largest group by count, holding 9.1% of the agree presses
The top five comments by vote

Ranked by upvotes. Left of the slash is agree, right is disagree. This is where the resentment actually sits.

  1. 1st 5918 ∕ 344 If foreigners are to be accepted, obeying Japanese law and rules is the precondition. Discrimination by nationality is wrong, but overlooking crime and rule-breaking is a separate matter. Building a system that prevents problems is the government's job 94% agreed (of agree plus disagree votes)
  2. 2nd 3489 ∕ 367 The Takaichi government is widening the intake of foreign workers because of the labour shortage, but has it done everything at home first? How seriously has it worked on pay rises and on work for women and older people? The intake should not be widened lightly 90% agreed (of agree plus disagree votes)
  3. 3rd 2223 ∕ 190 Immigration should not grow further; a total cap is better. The recent increase is abnormal and may turn into serious friction soon. Japanese-language ability and education should be checked strictly, and only the highly skilled people who are needed should be let in 92% agreed (of agree plus disagree votes)
  4. 4th 1495 ∕ 211 It looks stupid, but inside it is a tangle of obligations. Even those who set out with resolve end up not being allowed to act. In the end those with power and the organisations get their way. The system has become one that cannot be changed short of something extraordinary 87% agreed (of agree plus disagree votes)
  5. 5th 1377 ∕ 422 The words may be extreme, but the point is understandable. When many adults cannot talk about politics, stating a view at 17 is admirable. May a long life ahead be a fruitful one, shaped by many different opinions 76% agreed (of agree plus disagree votes)
Every number from this thread

I read all 2,243 parent comments, as they stood between 7:03 and 7:07am on 16 November 2026, about twenty-one hours after publication. The article showed 2,914 comments in total at about 7:07am, and at the time of reading the parent comments had 658 replies. The buttons came to 24,724 agree, 1,033 insightful and 7,256 disagree: 78 to 22. Agree against disagree alone is 3.4 to 1. The top comment alone holds 23.9% of the agree presses, the top three 47.0%, the top five 58.7%, the top ten 69.5% and the top twenty 78.8%. The most replies went to the 1st (143), the most insightful presses to the 4th (146) and the most disagree presses to the 5th (422). Of the 2,243 comments, 989 received no agree press and 634 received no press at all. In 415 comments disagree outnumbered agree, and they hold 49.9% of the thread's disagree presses. The average comment is 86.9 characters; the 830 comments under 40 characters hold 4.1% of the agree presses and the 688 of 100 characters or more hold 91.3%. 2,163 of the 2,243 have no reply. I counted what the comments say; one comment can fall into several groups. Comments about the intake of foreigners itself number 846, or 37.7%, and hold 76.3% of the agree presses. Comments about Yutabon as a person, the wording, or the article itself number 1,240, or 55.3%, and hold 29.0% of the agree presses and 48.9% of the disagree presses. Comments blaming the government or politicians: 319, or 14.2%, holding 48.2% of the agree presses, 31.9% without the 1st, 16.4% without the 1st and 2nd. Comments saying the government is not stupid, that it knows but cannot act or acts on purpose: 183, or 8.2%, with 2,072 agree presses in total, 8.4%, and 18.5% of the insightful presses; 2.5% without the 4th. Business and employers want cheap labour: 145 comments, 12.6%, or 7.0% without the 4th. Screen people and set conditions before entry: 131 comments, 41.8%. Stop or reduce the intake: 213 comments, or 9.5%, holding 33.0%. Make people obey the law and the rules: 185 comments, 27.7%, or 5.0% without the 1st. Comments saying any of these three: 432, or 19.3%, holding 64.6%, or 53.4% without the 1st. Worried about crime by foreigners and public safety: 133 comments, 29.1%. First raise pay and improve work for Japanese people: 83 comments, 17.7%, or 5.9% without the 1st and 2nd. Pointed to Europe or the US: 46 comments, 3.1%. Foreign workers are needed: 194 comments, or 8.6%, holding 2.7% of the agree presses and 18.4% of the disagree presses. Comments citing figures against the view that crime is rising: 157, holding 1.4% of the agree presses and 7.4% of the disagree presses. It is up to voters and elections: 115 comments, or 5.1%, holding 5.2% of the agree presses and 10.6% of the disagree presses. Comments blaming Prime Minister Takaichi or the cabinet by name: 27, holding 14.2%, or 0.2% without the 2nd; comments backing the prime minister: 27, holding 0.7%. Comments praising Yutabon for speaking up, or saying it is good for a young person to speak: 244, or 10.9%, holding 18.5% of the agree presses and 28.3% of the disagree presses. Comments criticising Yutabon personally: 850, or 37.9%, the largest group by count, holding 9.1% of the agree presses and 17.9% of the disagree presses. Comments criticising the wording "too stupid" or "ready to be flamed": 157, holding 7.2%. Comments saying this should not be an article: 153, holding 1.5%. Comments mentioning the father, the parents or the upbringing: 64, or 2.9%, with 1,545 agree presses in total, 6.2%; 1,377 of those belong to the 5th alone, and without it the total is 168, or 0.7%. The word for bureaucrats appears in 31 comments, with 343 agree presses of which 322 belong to the 11th. The word shigarami (ties and obligations) appears in 8 comments, and the words for "stupid" in 200. Comments blaming the left or the opposition: 78, holding 1.2%. Comments saying some politicians do not act for Japan: 39, holding 2.7%. I read the top 60 one by one and sorted the remaining 2,183 with the same table of categories, so the counts should be read as slightly approximate. The comment my lady shared ranks 4th by agree presses in this thread: 1,495 agree, 211 disagree.

Read to the end? A coffee keeps this ad-free. ☕ Buy me a coffee

Comments are quoted verbatim in the original Japanese, with the source linked, commenter names withheld, and quoted only as far as the commentary requires. Translations are mine. Source articles may expire (retrieval dates noted). The substance of this piece is the author's commentary.

Next