Former PM Ishiba asks whether 'what happens if the consumption tax is cut' can be understood in one minute.

2026-11-12 Money and politics 3,203 comments read

98

agree votes in total for the 99 saying one minute is enough

3,203 comments read to the bottom · every number is below

Where the agree votes went

Share of all agree presses on the 3,203 comments. One comment can count in more than one group.

  • Blamed Ishiba 91.2%
  • Mentioned election pledges 62.0%
  • Supported Prime Minister Takaichi / explained the approval favourably 53.1%
  • Mentioned Ishiba's time as prime minister 51.8%
  • For cutting the consumption tax 40.8%
  • Ishiba says one thing and does another 31.8%
  • Discussed the article, Bunshun, the media 20.7%
  • Leave the party / stop attacking from behind 19.3%
  • Prices, hardship in daily life 11.6%
  • The Takeshita cabinet, the introduction of the tax 9.7%
  • GDP ranking, economic decline 7.9%
  • Discussed the LDP as a party 5.1%
  • Social media, short videos, newspapers, television 4.5%
  • Not understandable in one minute / not a simple matter 4.1%
  • No need to worry about funding / funding talk is an excuse 3.7%
  • Looking down on voters 1.6%
  • Mentioned the Ministry of Finance 1.5%
  • Ishiba is right 1.2%
  • Against or doubtful about the cut 1.2%
  • Criticised Prime Minister Takaichi 0.9%
  • Show the funding / worried about debt 0.8%
  • Understandable in one minute / obvious 0.1%

My lady's reading

Reading this article, my lady said this.

Puonhime, the author - 'my lady' in the text

Whatever excuse comes from someone who did not do as promised, there is no reason to trust it

Conduct that eats away at Japan

Of course anyone can tell in one minute what happens when the consumption tax goes down

Consumers who no longer have to pay the consumption tax are glad. That is it

Does the public need to worry that much about the state's funding? There are people who at once ask "if taxes are cut, where is the funding?", but

That is my lady's reading.

Some of it can be counted. Did this thread trust what Ishiba said? How many comments say one minute is enough? Did the thread worry about funding? First, something the article does not say.

The news

The thread 「『消費税を減税すると何が起こるか』なんぞということが1分で分かりますかね?」《減税退席で戒告処分》石破茂前首相が語った“ショート動画政治”の問題点 Bunshun Online (via Yahoo! News) · retrieved 2026-11-12 open the original ↗

On the evening of 11 November 2026, Bunshun Online published an article on Yahoo! News.

On 6 November, former Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba left the chamber just before the lower house voted on a bill to cut the consumption tax on food. On 9 November the LDP gave Ishiba and three others a formal reprimand. The article is an interview with Ishiba by the weekly Shukan Bunshun.

Asked why the Takaichi government's approval rating does not fall, Ishiba answers: people have stopped reading newspapers and watching television, and more of them get information from social media, where only agreeable information gathers. "Stating a sharp conclusion in a short time" is in fashion, Ishiba says, and goes on: "Can something like 'what happens if the consumption tax is cut' be understood in one minute?"

Ishiba recalls Prime Minister Noboru Takeshita, who brought in the consumption tax, saying that "even if approval falls to 3 percent, what is needed will be done", and says: "saying only what goes down well feels very wrong." Asked why the Ishiba cabinet's own approval did not rise, the answer is: "Because I did not say things that sound good, perhaps."

Context for readers outside Japan

Yahoo! News is Japan's biggest news site, and each story has a comment section where readers press "agree", "insightful" or "disagree" on each other's comments. Japan's consumption tax is a sales tax, currently 8% on food and 10% on most other things; it was introduced at 3% in 1989 under Prime Minister Takeshita. Shigeru Ishiba was prime minister before Sanae Takaichi, who now leads the LDP. Japanese parties normally require members to vote as the party has decided; leaving the chamber before a vote is a way of neither voting for nor against.

What the article does not say

The article reports Ishiba's question: can it be understood in one minute? It does not say what Ishiba thinks does happen when the consumption tax is cut.

Earlier reports have a record of that. On 13 February 2026, five days after the lower house election: concern about a consumption tax cut, "if revenue falls, public finances are damaged" (a Nikkei headline). On 19 October, on television: "The aim is to bring prices down, but will prices really fall? It becomes unclear what the tax cut is for." On 10 September: "if the rate is not put back, the country is finished" (the headline of an interview in the San-in Chuo Shimpo). These come from the record I traced, in date order, for the note on the walkout of 6 November.

The article does not describe the bill either. According to reports on 6 November, it lowers the consumption tax on food and drink from the current 8% to 1% for two years from April 2027.

One more thing: the LDP's pledge in the February lower house election. According to a report from the day the manifesto was announced, the LDP wrote that it would "speed up consideration toward realising" the removal of food from the consumption tax for a limited two years, at a national council on social security and tax. Ishiba, too, was elected as an official candidate of the LDP that carried this pledge.

82 to 18: 3,203 comments, fourteen hours in

I read all 3,203 parent comments, as they stood between 6:18 and 6:22am on 12 November, about fourteen hours after publication. The article showed 3,850 comments in total at about 6:17am.

The buttons came to 92,239 agree, 2,682 insightful and 20,991 disagree presses. Positive presses against negative: 82 to 18.

The votes sit heavily at the top. The first comment alone holds 27.5% of the agree presses, the top 3 57.5%, the top 5 73.4%.

The comment my lady shared: 3rd

The reason Ms Takaichi's approval rating does not fall is surely that the effort to carry out election pledges is valued. Politicians often say pleasant things at election time, carry out nothing once elected, and in the end only raise taxes. On that point, with Ms Takaichi there is an expectation that "what was promised will be done". Many people probably have an impression different from the usual lawmaker. Mr Ishiba, on the other hand, produced no notable results, and the policies and vision were hard to see. Being asked to step down after about a year was only natural. Bunshun and Mr Ishiba teaming up - is that not the worst possible combination? Nothing productive can be felt in this interview.

高市さんの支持率が下がらないのは、公約を実現しようとする姿勢が評価されているからだと思う。政治家は選挙では耳ざわりのよいことを言っても、当選後は何も実行せず、結局は増税ばかりというケースも少なくない。 その点、高市さんには「やると言ったことは実行する」という期待感がある。一般的な議員とは異なる印象を持つ人も多いのだろう。 一方、石破氏は目立った成果を上げられず、政策やビジョンも見えにくかった。そのため、1年ほどで退陣を求められるのは当然だと思う。 文春と石破氏が組んだとしても、最悪の組み合わせではないか。この取材には、何の生産性も感じられない。
▲ 11,671 ・ ▼ 2,286retrieved 2026-11-12open the original ↗

3rd by votes: 11,671 agree, 170 insightful, 2,286 disagree, with 46 replies. This one comment holds 12.7% of the thread's agree presses.

The comment says the approval rating does not fall because the effort to carry out pledges is valued. Ishiba gave social media and "what goes down well" as the reason. To the same question, this comment answers: pledges.

Comments blaming Ishiba: 91.2% of the agree presses

The 2,324 comments blaming Ishiba are 72.6% of the thread and hold 91.2% of the agree presses. 15 of the top 20 are among them.

The 167 saying Ishiba is right are 5.2% of the thread and hold 1.2% - but 17.8% of the disagree presses. The highest is the 29th (175 agree, 198 disagree), which says the remark about social media gathering only agreeable information captures the mood of Japan today.

The 247 saying Ishiba says one thing and does another hold 31.8% of the agree presses. Nearly all of that is the first comment; without it, 6.0%. The first says Ishiba told another politician to leave the party if unable to follow its line, yet walked out without casting a no vote.

The 889 mentioning Ishiba's time as prime minister hold 51.8%. The 486 saying to leave the party, or to stop attacking from behind, hold 19.3%.

What this thread pressed was the pledge

The 237 comments mentioning election pledges are 7.4% of the thread. Yet those hold 62.0% of the agree presses, because the 1st, 2nd and 3rd all write about the pledge. Without those three, 10.8%.

The 397 supporting Prime Minister Takaichi, or explaining the approval rating favourably, hold 53.1%. The 233 criticising hold 0.9%.

The 328 for cutting the consumption tax hold 40.8% of the agree presses. The 120 against or doubtful hold 1.2% of the agree and 12.2% of the disagree presses.

The 4th comment answers Ishiba on the Takeshita cabinet.

The Noboru Takeshita cabinet, which introduced the 3% consumption tax, did so as part of a tax reform, and income tax and residence tax were lowered at the same time. In other words, a tax cut for the middle bracket came with it. That won the public's understanding. Now, with tax rises continuing - the special reconstruction income tax and others - is the idea this time not to ease the feeling of heavy taxation a little, and hope for a livelier economy, by lowering the consumption tax for two years on food alone? At the very least, ignoring that the background is different, and straining to give off an air of sound argument by comparison with Noboru Takeshita, who set the income tax at 3% - that is truly "saying what sounds good".

消費税3%を導入した竹下登内閣は、税制改革の推進の一環として行なっていたこともあり、同時に所得税や住民税の引き下げが行われた。すなわち中堅層に対する減税が同時に行われた。これは国民の理解が得られた。 復興特別所得税などが続くなど、増税が行われ続けている中で、食品だけに限って2年間、消費税を下げるということによって重税感を少しでも和らげて経済活性化を期待しているのが今回ではないだろうか。 少なくとも背景が異なっていることを無視して、所得税を3%にした竹下登と比較して正論のような雰囲気を出そうと奮闘しているところが、実に”調子のいいこと”である。
▲ 8,312 ・ ▼ 1,345retrieved 2026-11-12open the original ↗

4th by votes: 8,312 agree, 431 insightful, 1,345 disagree, with 54 replies. It hands Ishiba's own phrase - not saying things that sound good - straight back. (The comment writes "income tax at 3%"; the tax introduced at 3% was the consumption tax. The quotation is left as written.)

"One minute is enough": 99 comments, 98 agree presses in total

How did the thread answer Ishiba's "can it be understood in one minute?" 77 comments, 2.4% of the thread, use the words "one minute".

The comments saying the effect of the cut can be understood in one minute, or is obvious, number 99, 3.1% of the thread. Their agree presses total 98 - 0.1% of the 92,239. One comment says: "Never mind one minute, it is clear in an instant! The economy improves!" It has 2 agree presses.

The comments saying it cannot be understood in one minute, or is not a simple matter, number 28 and hold 4.1%. Nearly all of that is the 6th comment (3,078 agree), which opens: "What a tax cut leads to may indeed not be understandable in one minute." It goes on: that it is wrong to rebel once a policy carried in the election manifesto has reached the Diet is something anyone can understand in less than a minute.

The most-pressed "one minute" in this thread was not about the content of the tax cut. It was about the pledge.

"No need to worry about funding": 3.7%. "Show the funding": 0.8%

The 142 comments saying the public need not worry about funding, or that funding talk is an excuse, are 4.4% of the thread and hold 3.7% of the agree presses. The highest is the 8th (1,434 agree): use the tax revenue that came in above forecast, and if that is said to be short, Ishiba should explain by how much.

The 62 saying the funding must be shown, or worried about debt, are 1.9% and hold 0.8% - but 10.1% of the disagree presses. The 22nd (272 agree, 1,118 disagree) says consumption tax revenue is about 28 trillion yen a year and filling the gap with bonds would swell interest payments; it drew four times as many disagree as agree presses.

143 comments, 4.5% of the thread, use the word "funding" (zaigen).

Checking my lady's reading

My lady said: whatever excuse comes from someone who did not do as promised, there is no reason to trust it.

In this thread, comments blaming Ishiba hold 91.2% of the agree presses, and comments saying Ishiba is right 1.2%. The thread did not accept what Ishiba said. On that, the thread faces the same way as my lady's reading. The 247 comments saying Ishiba says one thing and does another hold 31.8% - 6.0% without the first comment. 37 comments use the character for "lie", with 55 agree presses in total.

Whether Ishiba failed to do as promised: the record I could trace runs like this. On the consumption tax, Ishiba said as prime minister in April 2025 that a cut limited to food was "not appropriate" (a Nikkei headline), and has kept speaking against a cut since. Within what I searched, I found no record of Ishiba saying the tax would be cut. On the other hand, Ishiba was elected as an official candidate of the LDP whose manifesto said it would "speed up consideration". This note does not say Ishiba lied, and does not say Ishiba did not.

My lady also said: conduct that eats away at Japan. Whether Ishiba is eating away at Japan cannot be counted. What could be counted is this much: 72.6% of the thread's comments blame Ishiba, and 15 of the top 20 do.

My lady also said: of course anyone can tell in one minute what happens when the consumption tax goes down; consumers who no longer have to pay it are glad. 99 comments say so. But their agree presses total 98, and none of the top 20 says it. The most-pressed comment on the point, the 6th, opens with "may indeed not be understandable in one minute". This thread did not argue with Ishiba over whether one minute is enough. Comments for the tax cut hold 40.8% of the agree presses, but what was pressed was not how easy it is to understand. It was whether a pledge is carried out. Here the thread does not match my lady's reading.

My lady also asked whether the public needs to worry that much about the state's funding. Comments saying there is no need hold 3.7% of the agree presses; comments saying the funding must be shown hold 0.8% and 10.1% of the disagree presses. The direction matches my lady's reading. Both numbers are small, though: comments on funding of either kind are 6.4% of the thread.

What I have not checked

This is the thread about fourteen hours after publication. Comments that came later are not in these counts. The site lists 3,204 parent comments; 1 could not be collected.

I have not checked what the first comment says: that Ishiba explored a consumption tax cut as prime minister and dropped it when the secretary-general objected, and that Ishiba told former Prime Minister Hatoyama to leave the party. 33 comments, with 176 agree presses in total, say Ishiba stated as prime minister that a pledge is not something that must always be carried out; I have not checked that statement either.

I have not checked the cuts in income and residence tax under the Takeshita cabinet that the 4th comment describes. I have not seen the source figures for the forecast in the article that Japan's GDP will rank sixth in the world next year, or for the approval ratings in the polls. The article is part of a feature in Shukan Bunshun, and I have not read the full interview.

I read the top 60 one by one, and sorted the other 3,143 with the same table of categories. Please read the counts as approximate. 231 comments use insulting words about people; they are counted, but those words are not quoted.

In closing

My lady said: of course anyone can tell in one minute what happens when the consumption tax goes down.

In this thread, 99 comments say one minute is enough, with 98 agree presses in total. Comments blaming Ishiba hold 91.2% of the agree presses, comments on the pledge 62.0%, comments supporting Prime Minister Takaichi 53.1%. Comments saying there is no need to worry about funding hold 3.7%, and comments saying the funding must be shown 0.8%. What Ishiba thinks does happen when the tax is cut is something the article did not say.

That is as far as counting goes.

82 to 18 The 92,239 agree and 2,682 insightful presses against 20,991 disagree, across 3,203 parent comments, as they stood on the morning of 12 November 2026, about fourteen hours after publication. The first comment alone holds 27.5% of the agree presses, the top 3 57.5%, the top 5 73.4%
91.2% The share of agree presses held by the 2,324 comments blaming Ishiba - 72.6% of the thread. The 167 saying Ishiba is right hold 1.2% of the agree presses and 17.8% of the disagree presses
98 presses The total agree presses on the 99 comments saying the effect of the tax cut can be understood in one minute - 0.1% of the 92,239. None of the top 20 comments says so
The top five comments by vote

Ranked by upvotes. Left of the slash is agree, right is disagree. This is where the resentment actually sits.

  1. 1st 25343 ∕ 3343 As prime minister, Ishiba explored a consumption tax cut, then dropped it when the party's secretary-general objected. Ishiba once told another politician to leave the party if unable to follow its line, yet walked out without casting a no vote. Compared with Ishiba, who did nothing, a prime minister trying to carry out a pledge obviously wins support 88% agreed (of agree plus disagree votes)
  2. 2nd 15988 ∕ 2040 Anyone can criticise. This cut is a temporary measure until incomes catch up with prices, and it is an LDP election pledge. Anyone against the pledge should have left the party and run without it. It is not too late: leave the party first, then stand by the conviction 88% agreed (of agree plus disagree votes)
  3. 3rd 11671 ∕ 2286 Prime Minister Takaichi's approval does not fall because the effort to carry out pledges is valued. There is an expectation that 'what was promised will be done'. Ishiba produced no notable results. Nothing productive can be felt in this interview (the comment my lady shared) 83% agreed (of agree plus disagree votes)
  4. 4th 8312 ∕ 1345 When the Takeshita cabinet brought in the 3% consumption tax, income and residence taxes were cut at the same time, and people accepted it. Now, with tax rises continuing, the cut on food for two years is meant to ease the weight. Ignoring that difference and invoking Takeshita is itself 'saying what sounds good' 86% agreed (of agree plus disagree votes)
  5. 5th 6371 ∕ 993 Ishiba and Bunshun should stop stirring anxiety without figures. The GDP ranking is the result of past governments doing nothing, and carrying on as before would lower it further. Let Prime Minister Takaichi's reforms go ahead, and debate in the Diet if a problem appears 86% agreed (of agree plus disagree votes)
Every number from this thread

I read all 3,203 parent comments, as they stood between 6:18 and 6:22am on 12 November 2026, about fourteen hours after publication. The article showed 3,850 comments in total at about 6:17am, and the parent comments had 655 replies. The buttons came to 92,239 agree, 2,682 insightful and 20,991 disagree presses - 82 to 18; agree against disagree alone, 4.4 to 1. The first comment alone holds 27.5% of the agree presses, the top 3 57.5%, the top 5 73.4%, the top 10 83.2%, the top 20 90.8%. The first also drew the most insightful presses, 856, and the most disagree presses, 3,343. 1,469 of the 3,203 got no agree press at all, and 1,003 got no press of any kind. 576 drew more disagree than agree presses, and they hold 32.6% of all the disagree presses. The average comment is 87.5 characters long; the 1,090 under 40 characters hold 0.9% of the agree presses, the 986 of 100 characters or more 98.1%. 254 of the 655 replies are on the top 2 comments, and 3,138 of the 3,203 have none. What did the thread say? The 2,324 comments (72.6%) blaming Ishiba hold 91.2% of the agree presses, 79.4% of the insightful and 65.6% of the disagree presses; without the first comment, 87.9%. The 167 (5.2%) saying Ishiba is right hold 1.2% of the agree and 17.8% of the disagree presses. The 724 saying neither hold 7.6%. The 247 (7.7%) saying Ishiba says one thing and does another hold 31.8%; without the first comment, 6.0%. The 889 (27.8%) mentioning Ishiba's time as prime minister hold 51.8%; without the first, 33.6%. The 486 saying to leave the party, or to stop attacking from behind, hold 19.3%, and the 172 saying voters are being looked down on 1.6%. The 237 (7.4%) mentioning election pledges hold 62.0% of the agree presses; without the top 3, 10.8%. The 397 (12.4%) supporting Prime Minister Takaichi, or explaining the approval rating favourably, hold 53.1%; without the first, 35.4%. The 233 criticising the prime minister hold 0.9% of the agree and 8.0% of the disagree presses. The 328 (10.2%) for cutting the consumption tax hold 40.8% of the agree presses; the 120 (3.7%) against or doubtful hold 1.2% of the agree and 12.2% of the disagree presses. The 99 (3.1%) saying the effect of the cut can be understood in one minute, or is obvious, hold 98 agree presses in total. The 28 saying it cannot be understood in one minute, or is not a simple matter, hold 4.1%, nearly all of it on the 6th comment; without the 6th, 0.8%. 77 comments use the words 'one minute'. The 142 (4.4%) saying the public need not worry about funding, or that funding talk is an excuse, hold 3.7% of the agree and 3.1% of the disagree presses. The 62 (1.9%) saying the funding must be shown, or worried about debt, hold 0.8% of the agree and 10.1% of the disagree presses. The 257 discussing social media, short videos, newspapers or television hold 4.5% of the agree and 16.7% of the disagree presses. The 244 discussing the article, Bunshun or the media hold 20.7%, the 267 on prices and hardship in daily life 11.6%, the 101 on the Takeshita cabinet or the introduction of the tax 9.7%, the 102 on the GDP ranking or economic decline 7.9%, the 307 discussing the LDP as a party 5.1%, the 82 mentioning the Ministry of Finance 1.5%. 37 comments use the character for 'lie', with 55 agree presses in total. As for which comment goes where: I read the top 60 one by one, and sorted the other 3,143 with the same table of categories, so please read the counts as approximate. The comment my lady shared ranks 3rd in this thread, with 11,671 agree and 2,286 disagree presses.

Read to the end? A coffee keeps this ad-free. ☕ Buy me a coffee

Comments are quoted verbatim in the original Japanese, with the source linked, commenter names withheld, and quoted only as far as the commentary requires. Translations are mine. Source articles may expire (retrieval dates noted). The substance of this piece is the author's commentary.

Next