A climber is missing on closed Mt.
1.9%
of agree votes go to comments that speak ill of a people as such
4,338 comments read to the bottom · every number is below
The most-agreed comment
Over the man missing on closed Mt. Fuji, the father is said to have offered about 12 million yen to whoever finds the man, and about 2.4 million yen even for finding the body. With that much to spare, the family should take responsibility for the rescue costs. If a large reward draws amateurs onto a dangerous mountain, it will not help the search; it will invite secondary accidents and may put rescuers and other climbers in danger. How much of a burden entering a closed mountain places on everyone around needs to be considered calmly. Mt. Fuji is not a place that becomes safe through a parent's love or a large sum of money.
Show original Japanese
閉山中の富士山で行方不明となった男性をめぐり、父親が発見者に約1200万円、遺体発見でも約240万円の謝礼を示したという。そんな余裕があるのなら救助費用を責任を持って負担するべきだ。高額な懸賞金が素人を危険な山へ誘えば捜索どころか二次遭難を招き、救助隊や別の登山者まで危険にさらしかねない。閉山中の入山が周囲にどれほどの負担をかけるのか冷静に考える必要がある。富士山は親心や大金で安全になる場所ではない。My lady's reading
After reading the article, my lady said this.
Behaviour that is a nuisance wherever it happens
"Only some," people say, yet that "some" is larger than Japan's whole population. Astonishing
What is being done is the nuisance
Communism is a cancer on this Earth
Behaviour with zero consideration for others
Goods and money over heart. A poor, shabby emperor with no clothes
That is my lady's reading. The first, third and fifth lines were rewritten from my lady's words so that they point at behaviour, not at people.
"That 'some' is larger than Japan's population" is how it feels to my lady; it has not been counted or checked. The line about communism is likewise my lady's view of a system of government.
Some of this can be counted. Did the thread call it a nuisance? How many comments lumped a country or a people together, and how much agreement did they draw? What did the thread say about the money? First, what the article does not say.
The news
At midday on 17 November 2026, TV Asahi (ANN) published an article on Yahoo! News.
Mt. Fuji is closed to climbers outside the summer season. The article says a Chinese man in his twenties went missing on the closed mountain, and that 17 November was the ninth day since contact was lost. Police and others are still searching; the man has not been found. The man's father arrived in Japan on 13 November.
According to Chinese media, the family says it will pay rescuers 500,000 yuan (about 12 million yen) if the man is found, and 100,000 yuan (about 2.4 million yen) as a token of thanks even if only the body is found. The article adds that it is not clear how the money would be shared, or whether it will actually be paid. An expert on mountain rescue says a reward may draw people onto the mountain, and asks people not to climb in winter.
What the article does not say
The article is short. It does not say where the man started from, with what equipment, or why the man entered a closed mountain. It does not say whether the man was alone.
It does not say what the search is costing, or who pays. It does not say whether climbing in the closed season is against the law, or whether there is any penalty.
The reward is reported at second hand, as something Chinese media said. In what words the family spoke, and to whom, cannot be known from the article.
96.5 to 3.5: 4,338 comments, eighteen and a half hours in
I read all 4,338 parent comments, loaded between 7:27 and 7:34 on the morning of 18 November, about eighteen and a half hours after publication. The article's total comment count was 4,968 at about 7:27.
The buttons: 89,683 agree, 2,051 insightful, 3,325 disagree. Presses in favour against presses pushing back come to 96.5 to 3.5. This is a thread with very few disagree presses.
The top comment alone holds 31.9% of the agree presses, the top two 50.4%, the top five 67.7%. Agreement is concentrated on a handful of comments at the top.
The comment my lady shared: 1,156th
How much trouble has to be caused before it is enough? Is it impossible to imagine that, by ignoring the rules, someone will be put in danger for the rescue?
どこまで迷惑掛ければ気が済むのだろうか。ルール無視してその救助のために誰かが危うい目にあうとは考えることができないのだろうか。It ranks 1,156th: 1 agree, 0 insightful, 0 disagree, no replies.
The comment says that ignoring the rules puts someone else in danger for the rescue. It names no country. Almost no buttons were pressed on it, but what it says points the same way as the comments that drew the most agreement in this thread.
What drew the most agreement: rescuers' lives, and the cost
(This is the most-agreed comment, shown at the top of this page.)
It ranks 1st: 28,620 agree, 395 insightful, 267 disagree, 251 replies. This one comment holds 31.9% of the thread's agree presses.
The 1st comment names no country. It writes about rescue costs, secondary accidents and the danger to rescuers.
Comments about the lives and families of rescuers number 382 and hold 73.7% of the agree presses. The 914 saying the climber who entered a closed mountain is responsible hold 60.4%, and the 903 saying the reward invites secondary accidents hold 50.5%.
Calls to change the rules also sit at the top. The 2nd (16,585 agree) wants closed-season rescue taken out of public rescue and limited to paid private services; the 3rd (7,071) wants closed-season climbing made an offence; the 5th (4,202) wants the system changed so the climber pays.
That money should pay for the rescue; no public rescue; charge for it; penalties. Comments in any of these four groups number 1,646 and hold 74.8% of the agree presses, or 62.9% even without the 1st.
Speaking ill of a country or a people as such: 877 comments, 1.9%
Comments that lump a country or a people together and speak ill of them number 877, or 20.2% of the thread. One in five. That is not a small number.
But they hold 1,700 agree presses in total, 1.9% of the 89,683. The highest of them ranks 23rd with 196 agree presses; none is in the top twenty. 356 of the 877 have no agree press at all.
Among them, the comments that say nothing about rescue costs or rules, only about a country or a people, number 468 and hold 1.1%. Comments calling for visits or entry to be stopped number 165 and hold 0.7%.
On the other side, comments that never name a country and never speak ill of a country or a people number 3,101, or 71.5% of the thread, and hold 92.7% of the agree presses. The 1st to the 6th comments are all among them.
"Nationality is not the issue": 76 comments
My lady said: "only some," people say.
In this thread, comments saying nationality is not the issue, that Japanese people would be the same, or that people should not be lumped together number 76, or 1.8%. They hold 1,013 agree presses, 1.1%. Of those, 787 belong to the 13th comment; without it the share is 0.3%.
The 13th says the family's feelings are understandable but the reward invites secondary accidents, and then: "This is not a matter of nationality." The 41st (101 agree) writes "I would like to think this is not national character," and goes on to say that causing trouble on a scale that may cost a life, by breaking the rules, is nothing other than real trouble.
Comments that lump people together, and comments that object to lumping people together, both sit on the side with little agreement. Most comments write about what was done, without writing about the country.
On the money, the thread says: use it to pay the costs
My lady said: goods and money over heart.
Comments saying the family is trying to settle it with money, or asking why alive is priced high and dead low, number 441, or 10.2%. They hold 1,398 agree presses, 1.6%. The 22nd (255 agree) notes that the risk to searchers is the same either way, and finds a high price alive and a low price dead somewhat mercenary.
Comments criticising the family number 778 and hold 2.9%. Comments asking whether the reward will really be paid number 461 and hold 1.7%. The 97th (24 agree) says an apology and an offer to cover the costs should have come first.
Yet on money, the view that drew the most agreement was not that there is no heart; it was that the money should pay for the rescue: 390 comments, 34.5% of the agree presses. Almost all of that is the 1st comment; without it the share is 3.8%.
Comments saying the parents' feelings are understandable number 185, or 4.3%, and hold 15.7% of the agree presses. They also hold 58.7% of the thread's disagree presses. The comment with the most disagree presses, the 21st (279 agree, 742 disagree), says it cannot bring itself to blame the family one-sidedly. The 7th (3,470 agree, 541 disagree) says the reward shows a family for whom 12 million yen is nothing against a son's life, and asks readers to take that into account.
Almost no comments mention communism
My lady said: communism is a cancer on this Earth.
Comments containing the word for communist number 9, with 18 agree presses in total. Widened to any mention of the Chinese government, the Communist Party or the travel advisory, there are 141 comments, 3.3% of the thread, with 624 agree presses, 0.7%. Of those, 193 belong to the 25th comment, which asks why anyone is climbing Mt. Fuji when the Chinese government has advised against travel to Japan.
The thread hardly talks about a system of government. What it blames is the rules on the Japanese side: 121 comments say Japanese authorities and law fall short, holding 5.4% of the agree presses, or 0.7% without the 5th.
Checking my lady's reading
My lady said: behaviour that is a nuisance wherever it happens; what is being done is the nuisance.
Comments containing the word for nuisance number 416, or 9.6% of the thread, and hold 1.1% of the agree presses. But comments saying the same thing without the word sit at the top. Comments saying the climber is responsible hold 60.4%, and comments about rescuers' lives hold 73.7%. That the behaviour is the nuisance: on this, my lady's reading and the thread agree.
My lady said: "only some," yet that "some" is larger than Japan's population. Comments lumping a country or a people together number 877, but hold 1.9% of the agree presses. 92.7% of the thread's agreement went to comments that name no country. Here my lady's reading and the thread do not match.
My lady said: behaviour with zero consideration for others. Comments saying the reward invites secondary accidents, and that rescuers have families too, fill the top of the thread. The view that other people's lives were not being considered is the thickest part of this thread. Two comments contain the word for consideration.
My lady said: goods and money over heart. Comments saying the family is trying to settle it with money hold 1.6%. Comments saying that money should pay for the rescue hold 34.5%. And comments saying the parents' feelings are understandable hold 15.7%.
My lady said communism is a cancer on this Earth. Nine comments contain the word, with 18 agree presses. The thread does not look that way.
Whether there is an emperor with no clothes cannot be counted here. What can be counted is what this thread wrote.
What I have not checked
This is the thread as it stood about eighteen and a half hours after publication. Later comments are not in these counts.
I read this article only. I have not read the original Chinese reports about the reward. I have not looked into what the search costs, who pays for it, or whether there is a penalty for climbing in the closed season.
My lady's line that the "some" is larger than Japan's population has not been counted or checked. The 25th comment's statement that the Chinese government has advised against travel has not been checked here either. Nor has anything the comments say about how the man entered the mountain.
I read the top 60 comments one by one and sorted the remaining 4,278 with the same coding table, so the counts carry some margin. There are 877 comments that speak ill of a country or a people as such, and 178 that use insulting words about the missing man or the family. They are counted, and their words are not quoted.
The man has not been found.
Closing
My lady said: behaviour that is a nuisance wherever it happens.
In this thread, 877 comments, one in five, speak ill of a country or a people as such. They hold 1.9% of the agree presses. Comments about rescue costs and rules hold 74.8%, and comments that never name a country hold 92.7%. Comments saying the parents' feelings are understandable hold 15.7% of the agree presses and 58.7% of the disagree presses.
That is as far as counting goes.
The top five comments by vote
Ranked by upvotes. Left of the slash is agree, right is disagree. This is where the resentment actually sits.
- 1st 28620 ∕ 267 With that much to spare, the family should take responsibility for the rescue costs. A large reward that draws amateurs onto a dangerous mountain invites secondary accidents and puts rescuers and other climbers at risk. Mt. Fuji does not become safe through a parent's love or a large sum
- 2nd 16585 ∕ 106 Rescue during the closed season should in principle fall outside public rescue and be limited to paid private services. It is unreasonable that a reckless decision puts rescuers' lives in danger. Making this clear in advance would also deter reckless climbs
- 3rd 7071 ∕ 95 Climbing during the closed season should be an offence, and such climbers should not be eligible for rescue. Risking lives to rescue someone who broke the rules on purpose is hard to bear. Rescuers have families too. With such a law, reckless climbs would decrease
- 4th 4281 ∕ 76 A careless reward is likely to cause secondary accidents. Mt. Fuji in winter is the harshest mountain in Japan, and if several people go up for the reward, more people will certainly die. Assembling a team of skilled people would be better than that
- 5th 4202 ∕ 50 The system should be changed so that search and rescue in the closed season are paid by the climber. Rescuers risk their lives, and the cost comes from taxes. It concerns both Shizuoka and Yamanashi, so the national government should act first
Every number from this thread
I read all 4,338 parent comments, as loaded between 7:27 and 7:34 on the morning of 18 November 2026, about eighteen and a half hours after publication. The article's total comment count was 4,968 at about 7:27, and the parent comments carried 593 replies when loaded. The buttons: 89,683 agree, 2,051 insightful and 3,325 disagree, or 96.5 to 3.5. Agree against disagree alone is 27.0 to 1. The top comment alone holds 31.9% of the agree presses, the top two 50.4%, the top three 58.3%, the top five 67.7%, the top ten 81.2%, the top twenty 87.7%. The most replies went to the 1st comment (251), the most insightful presses also to the 1st (395), and the most disagree presses to the 21st (742). Of the 4,338 comments, 1,986 have no agree press and 1,784 have no button pressed at all. Disagree outnumbers agree on 81 comments, which hold 44.6% of the thread's disagree presses. The average comment is 59.3 characters; the 2,078 comments under 40 characters hold 2.9% of the agree presses, and the 705 of 100 characters or more hold 92.9%. 4,254 of the 4,338 have no reply. I counted what the comments say; one comment can fall into several groups. Comments about the lives and families of rescuers: 382, or 8.8%, holding 73.7% of the agree presses, 61.4% without the 1st. Comments saying the climber who entered a closed mountain is responsible, or reckless: 914, or 21.1%, holding 60.4%. Comments saying the reward invites secondary accidents: 903, or 20.8%, holding 50.5%, 27.3% without the 1st. Comments saying that money should pay for the rescue: 390, or 9.0%, holding 34.5%, 3.8% without the 1st. Comments saying closed-season climbers should be outside public rescue, the search should stop, or wait until spring: 874, or 20.1%, holding 32.6%; comments calling for rescue to be charged: 391, holding 27.6%; comments calling for penalties for entering in the closed season: 345, holding 10.4%. Comments in any of these four groups: 1,646, or 37.9%, holding 74.8%, 62.9% without the 1st. Comments saying leave it to professionals or hire them privately: 159, holding 21.7%. Comments saying the parents' feelings are understandable: 185, or 4.3%, holding 15.7% of the agree presses and 58.7% of the disagree presses. Comments criticising the family: 778, or 17.9%, holding 2.9%. Comments saying the family is trying to settle it with money, or asking why alive is priced high and dead low: 441, or 10.2%, with 1,398 agree presses in total, 1.6%. Comments asking whether the reward will really be paid: 461, or 10.6%, holding 1.7%. Comments about going or not going for the reward: 254, holding 4.4%, 0.5% without the 7th. Comments saying the man is probably no longer alive, or wait for the thaw: 301, holding 9.0%. Comments that speak ill of a country or a people as such: 877, or 20.2%, with 1,700 agree presses in total, 1.9%, and 1.4% of the disagree presses. The highest of them ranks 23rd with 196 agree presses, none is in the top twenty, and 356 of the 877 have no agree press. Of them, the comments that say nothing about rescue costs or rules: 468, holding 1.1%. Comments calling for visits or entry to be stopped: 165, holding 0.7%. Comments saying nationality is not the issue, or that Japanese people would be the same: 76, or 1.8%, with 1,013 agree presses in total, 1.1%, of which 787 belong to the 13th comment; without the 13th the share is 0.3%. Comments mentioning the Chinese government, the Communist Party or the travel advisory: 141, or 3.3%, with 624 agree presses, 0.7%, of which 193 belong to the 25th. Comments containing the word for communist: 9, with 18 agree presses; the word for race: 22, with 16; the word for nuisance: 416, holding 1.1%. Comments saying Japanese authorities and law fall short: 121, holding 5.4%, 0.7% without the 5th. Comments calling Mt. Fuji a mountain of faith: 61, holding 1.3%; comments criticising the reporting: 54, holding 0.3%. Comments using insulting words about the missing man or the family: 178, holding 1.1%. Comments that never name a country and never speak ill of a country or a people: 3,101, or 71.5%, holding 92.7% of the agree presses. I read the top 60 comments one by one and sorted the remaining 4,278 with the same coding table, so the counts carry some margin. The comment my lady shared ranks 1,156th in this thread, with 1 agree press.
Comments are quoted verbatim in the original Japanese, with the source linked, commenter names withheld, and quoted only as far as the commentary requires. Translations are mine. Source articles may expire (retrieval dates noted). The substance of this piece is the author's commentary.