NHK names the line-up for Kohaku, the New Year's Eve song contest.
34.9%
of agree votes say Kohaku is no longer what it was
2,853 comments read to the bottom · every number is below
The most-agreed comment
Until the Showa and Heisei eras, many households probably watched with the whole family, sitting around the heated table. I think the singers chosen were those with many hits of the day, and the great names without whom the show would not come alive. Many times I saw a singer overcome with emotion, unable to go on, while another singer gently put an arm around that singer's shoulder and sang along. With emotion and laughter, it was a programme worth watching that let people feel the year was being put to rest. Sadly, at some point, that charm disappeared.
Show original Japanese
昭和、平成の頃まではコタツに入りながら、家族全員で見ていた家庭も多いのではないでしょうか。その時代にヒット曲を多く出された歌手や、この大御所の出演なくしては盛り上がらない、といった方々が選ばれていたと思います。
感極まって途中から歌えなくなった歌手を、他の歌手が横からそっと肩を抱きながら、一緒に歌うシーンなど何度も見ました。
感動あり、笑いありの一年を納める気持ちにさせる見応えのある番組でした。
でも残念ながら、そんな魅力は、いつの頃からか無くなってしまいました。My lady's reading
On reading the article, my lady said this.
Hard to call it a year-end tradition of Japan any more
Distrust of NHK, the state broadcaster of Japan; the reasons the performers were chosen
The prestige of having appeared on Kohaku
All of it an empty image, vanity
That is my lady's reading.
One note on a word. My lady said "state broadcaster". NHK is not run by the state: it is a public broadcaster set up under the Broadcasting Act and funded by receiving fees paid by households. Seven comments in this thread also write "state-run".
Some of this can be counted. Does the thread still see Kohaku as a year-end tradition? How far does it doubt NHK and the selection? Does it still write of appearing on Kohaku as an honour? And how many comments call the whole thing hollow, all show? First, what the article does not say.
The news
On the afternoon of 13 November 2026, Sponichi Annex published an article on Yahoo! News.
Kohaku Uta Gassen, the "Red and White Song Contest", is the music programme NHK has broadcast on New Year's Eve for decades. Female acts form the red team, male acts the white team. The acts for the 77th edition were announced at a press conference on the 13th: 20 for the red team and 21 for the white team, 41 in all.
According to the article, seven acts appear for the first time, among them =LOVE, CUTIE STREET and EBiDAN. Separately, as a "special project", Koshi Inaba appears solo for the first time and sings "Touch", the theme song of a 1985 animated series. Sayuri Ishikawa appears for the 49th time, Mizue Takada for the 8th and Anri for the 4th.
This year's theme is "Let's go beyond, together with song". The hosts are the actors Masato Sakai, Kazunari Ninomiya and Mana Ashida, with the NHK announcer Naoko Suzuki. The white team won last year for the second year running; the all-time record is 34 wins for red and 42 for white, the article says.
What the article does not say
The article reports the list of acts. Its text does not say by what criteria the acts were chosen.
Below the article is a row of links to other Sponichi Annex pieces. One headline says NHK announced the selection criteria as "activity this year", "public support" and "the programme's plan and staging". Other headlines say that Hiroshi Miyama (known for a kendama record attempt during the song), Aimyon and Kenshi Yonezu are not on the list, and that K-pop groups fell to two (from six two years ago). I read only those headlines, not the pieces themselves.
The article gives no ratings for Kohaku, no production cost and no performance fees.
70 to 30: 2,853 comments, seventeen and a half hours in
I read all 2,853 parent comments, as they stood between 6:35 and 6:40am on 14 November, about seventeen and a half hours after publication. The article showed 3,635 comments in total at about 6:41am.
The buttons came to 35,111 agree, 4,018 insightful and 17,128 disagree. Positive presses against push-back presses: 70 to 30. It is a thread with many disagree presses.
The first comment alone holds 19.3% of the agree presses, the top 3 28.8%, the top 5 35.4%.
The comment my lady shared: 262nd
Whether a programme like this is worth the receiving fee is quite doubtful. In the days before the internet flourished it would certainly have been one of the channels to choose from, but is it needed in this day and age? If events like this are counted as one of the grounds for the receiving fee, handing it to another broadcaster would be no different, or even a gain, with no fee to pay. Now that the call for tax cuts has become mainstream, whatever can be trimmed should be trimmed as far as possible; even one yen of relief feels necessary.
こういった番組が受信料に見合うかと言われるとかなり疑問。確かにネットが栄えていなかった時代ならチャンネルの選択肢に入っただろうが、今の時代に必要だろうか?こういった催しが受信料の根拠の一つとされているなら、別に他局に譲っても同じ、もしくは受信料がない分得なのでは?と思う。減税論が主流になっている今、削れる部分は可能な限り削り、負担軽減が1円でも必要に感じる。262nd in the thread: 11 agree, 0 insightful, 8 disagree, no replies.
The comment asks whether the programme is worth the receiving fee and whether it is needed today. 144 comments in the thread mention receiving fees or production cost, holding 8.1% of the agree presses. 111 say Kohaku should end or shrink, holding 3.0%. The 15th comment (326 agree) says that if NHK keeps running a deficit, large and costly entertainment programmes are the first thing to review.
"Kohaku is no longer what it was": 34.9%, and the first comment says so
408 comments, 14.3% of the thread, say Kohaku is no longer what it was, has lost its charm, or is no longer watched by the whole family. They hold 34.9% of the agree presses, more than any other heading.
(This is the most-agreed comment, shown at the top of this page.)
First in the thread: 6,772 agree, 507 insightful, 842 disagree, 114 replies. This one comment holds 19.3% of the agree presses. Without it, the share for "no longer what it was" is 19.3%.
324 comments say the writer does not watch any more, holding 4.8%. 196 say the acts are unfamiliar, holding 4.0%. Comments saying any of the three number 793, 27.8% of the thread, and hold 40.2% of the agree presses.
The word for a seasonal tradition (fubutsushi) appears in 14 comments, with 46 agree presses in total. The 102nd comment (39 agree) writes that the feeling of a year-end fixture of Japan is gone.
Questioning the selection: 16.6%. Blaming NHK itself: 7.0%
335 comments, 11.7% of the thread, question how acts are chosen: unclear criteria, no hit this year, the power of agencies. They hold 16.6% of the agree presses, or 8.8% without the 3rd and 4th comments.
620 comments, 21.7% of the thread, say a particular act was left out. That is the largest group by count, holding 18.9% of the agree presses. The 4th comment (1,475 agree) regrets that Juice=Juice, much talked about this year, is absent, and wonders whether strong connections are needed after all. 84 comments name Juice=Juice. The 12th (394 agree) cannot accept that the enka singer Keisuke Yamauchi was passed over for a second year.
154 comments, 5.4%, blame NHK itself, holding 7.0% of the agree presses. Nearly all of that is the 3rd comment (1,517 agree); without it the share is 2.8%. The 3rd comment writes of "nothing but strong distrust" of NHK's attitude and asks for a review of the role of a public broadcaster and of the transparency of selection. The word "distrust" appears in 3 comments, the 3rd included.
"Still an honour": 6 comments. "No longer the old weight": 26
6 comments say appearing on Kohaku is still an honour or a goal for singers, holding 0.9% of the agree presses. Nearly all of that is the 19th comment (311 agree), which says that whatever the public says, appearing is surely an honour for the performers. The word for prestige gained (haku) appears in 1 comment, with 1 agree press.
26 comments say appearing no longer carries the old weight, or that singers decline. They hold 3.0%, again nearly all of it one comment, the 5th (846 agree); without it the share is 0.6%. The 64th (61 agree) writes that appearing on Kohaku once carried weight like appearing at the Olympics, and that the weight now seems gone.
Both are small topics here. What the thread wrote about was less the value of appearing than who was chosen and who was not.
"Hollow, all show": 32 comments, 110 agree presses in total
32 comments, 1.1% of the thread, call Kohaku hollow, all show, no longer a song contest, or kept going out of habit. Their agree presses total 110, 0.3% of the 35,111. None of the top 20 comments says so. The highest is the 160th (24 agree).
No comment in the thread uses the words for "empty image" (kyozo) or "vanity" (kyoei).
Comments glad about the line-up: 19.5%
439 comments, 15.4% of the thread, are glad about a chosen act or look forward to one. They hold 19.5% of the agree presses. 159 are glad to see acts from the Showa and Heisei eras, holding 9.5%. The 7th comment (659 agree) is surprised by the return of Mizue Takada; the 8th (647 agree) hopes Misato Watanabe and TM NETWORK perform together.
164 comments look forward to Kohaku as a programme or say it still has a role, holding 9.2% of the agree presses. The 14th (360 agree) says its role now is probably to be a place where viewers meet singers not known before. These comments also hold 18.2% of the disagree presses. The 25th, which says Kohaku is a pleasure every year, has 175 agree presses against 562 disagree.
97 comments welcome the fall in Korean groups, holding 9.7%, or 5.6% without the 3rd. 13 regret it, holding 0.1%. 331 discuss enka, holding 8.2%. 77 ask for real singing rather than lip-sync, holding 4.9%.
Checking my lady's reading
My lady said: hard to call it a year-end tradition of Japan any more.
The 408 comments saying Kohaku is no longer what it was hold 34.9% of the agree presses, and the first comment says exactly that. With "do not watch" and "do not know the acts", the share is 40.2%. The direction matches. Without the first comment, though, the share is 19.3%, level with the 19.5% for comments glad about a chosen act. The thread is made of both: voices looking back, and voices enjoying this year's names. Whether Kohaku has stopped being a tradition cannot be told from these counts. The article gives no ratings.
My lady also said: distrust of NHK, and the reasons the performers were chosen. Comments questioning the selection hold 16.6%; comments blaming NHK itself hold 7.0%. The direction matches. Nearly all the agree presses blaming NHK belong to the 3rd comment, however; without it the share is 2.8%. What the thread wrote most often was not about NHK as a broadcaster. It was the 620 comments saying a particular act was left out.
My lady also said: the prestige of having appeared on Kohaku. Six comments say appearing is still an honour; 26 say it no longer carries the old weight. Each figure rests on one high-ranked comment, and the thread hardly argued the point.
And my lady said: all of it an empty image, vanity. The 32 comments calling Kohaku hollow hold 110 agree presses in total, and none is in the top 20. Here the thread does not match my lady's reading. The thread does not write of Kohaku as empty. It remembers a programme once worth watching, and argues over who appears this year. Whether Kohaku is an empty image is not something I can count.
What I have not checked
This is the thread about seventeen and a half hours after publication. Comments added later are not in these counts. The site listed 2,869 parent comments; 16 could not be collected.
I did not watch the press conference. I read this article and the headlines listed beneath it. I have not looked into the content of NHK's selection criteria or how the selection proceeded.
I have not checked the 3rd comment's account of an uproar over selection at last year's Kohaku, the 15th comment's figure of a 69 billion yen deficit in NHK's fiscal 2026 budget, or the 5th comment's statement that many singers decline. I found no support for the view, as in the 4th comment's "strong connections", that agency power decides the list.
I read the top 60 comments one by one and sorted the remaining 2,793 with the same table of headings, so the counts carry some margin. 22 comments use insulting words about people; those are counted, and the words are not quoted.
Closing
My lady said: hard to call it a year-end tradition of Japan any more, and all of it an empty image, vanity.
In this thread, comments saying Kohaku is no longer what it was hold 34.9% of the agree presses. Comments questioning the selection hold 16.6%; comments blaming NHK itself, 7.0%. The 32 calling it hollow hold 110 presses in total. On the other side, comments glad about a chosen act hold 19.5%, and 620 comments say a particular act was left out.
That is as far as the counting goes.
The top five comments by vote
Ranked by upvotes. Left of the slash is agree, right is disagree. This is where the resentment actually sits.
- 1st 6772 ∕ 842 Until the Showa and Heisei eras many families probably watched together, sitting around the heated table. With emotion and laughter, it was a programme worth watching that let people feel the year was closing. Sadly, at some point, that charm disappeared
- 2nd 1829 ∕ 314 Is it because of the writer's own age that Kohaku seems duller every year? In childhood it was watched late into the night with the family, with excitement. Many group names on the white team are in English. Congratulations to the first-timers
- 3rd 1517 ∕ 240 NHK ignored viewers and low ratings and kept leaning toward acts from one particular country; there is nothing but strong distrust of that attitude. This year looks like a course correction at last, but the role of a public broadcaster and the transparency of selection should be reviewed from the ground up
- 4th 1475 ∕ 306 It is a great pity that Juice=Juice, so much talked about this year, is not appearing. If even this is not enough, it feels as if nothing Hello! Project does will ever be enough. Perhaps strong connections are needed after all
- 5th 846 ∕ 284 For all the criticism, Kohaku is safe as long as its line-up makes news outside NHK; no other programme does that. Still, it used to be the stage singers longed for, and now, with long hours of commitment, many decline, so finding acts willing to appear must be the harder task
Every number from this thread
I read all 2,853 parent comments, as they stood between 6:35 and 6:40am on 14 November 2026, about seventeen and a half hours after publication. The article showed 3,635 comments in total at about 6:41am, and at the time of reading the parent comments had 748 replies. The buttons came to 35,111 agree, 4,018 insightful and 17,128 disagree - 70 to 30. Agree against disagree alone is 2.0 to 1. The first comment alone holds 19.3% of the agree presses, the top 3 28.8%, the top 5 35.4%, the top 10 43.8%, the top 20 53.6%. The first comment also has the most insightful presses (507), disagree presses (842) and replies (114) in the thread. Of the 2,853 comments, 617 have no agree press and 154 have no press of any kind. In 854 comments disagree outnumbers agree, and those hold 47.7% of the disagree presses. The average comment is 49.3 characters; the 1,681 under 40 characters hold 13.4% of the agree presses and the 328 of 100 or more hold 69.8%. 2,684 of the 2,853 have no reply. I counted what the comments say; one comment can fall under several headings. Comments saying Kohaku is no longer what it was, has lost its charm, or is no longer watched by the whole family: 408, or 14.3%, holding 34.9% of the agree presses and 20.0% of the disagree presses; 19.3% without the first comment, 14.6% without the top 3. Comments saying the writer does not watch any more: 324, or 11.4%, holding 4.8%. Comments saying the acts are unfamiliar: 196, holding 4.0%. Comments saying any of the three: 793, or 27.8%, holding 40.2%, or 25.9% without the first. The word for a seasonal tradition (fubutsushi) appears in 14 comments with 46 agree presses in total. Comments questioning how acts are chosen - unclear criteria, the power of agencies: 335, or 11.7%, holding 16.6%, or 8.8% without the 3rd and 4th. Comments saying a particular act was left out: 620, or 21.7%, the largest group by count, holding 18.9%, or 15.3% without the 4th. Comments blaming NHK itself: 154, or 5.4%, holding 7.0%, or 2.8% without the 3rd. Comments mentioning receiving fees or production cost: 144, holding 8.1%, or 4.0% without the 3rd. The word 'distrust' appears in 3 comments; of their 1,520 agree presses, 1,517 belong to the 3rd comment. 'State-run' appears in 7 comments with 30 presses in total. Comments saying Kohaku should end or shrink: 111, holding 3.0%. Comments saying appearing is still an honour: 6, holding 0.9%, or 0.0% without the 19th. Comments saying appearing no longer carries the old weight: 26, holding 3.0%, or 0.6% without the 5th. The word for prestige gained (haku) appears in 1 comment with 1 press. Comments calling Kohaku hollow, all show, or no longer a song contest: 32, or 1.1%, with 110 agree presses in total, 0.3%. No comment uses the words for 'empty image' (kyozo) or 'vanity' (kyoei). On the other side, comments glad about a chosen act: 439, or 15.4%, holding 19.5% of the agree presses and 27.6% of the disagree presses. Comments glad to see Showa and Heisei era acts: 159, holding 9.5%. Comments looking forward to Kohaku or saying it still has a role: 164, holding 9.2% of the agree presses and 18.2% of the disagree presses. Comments welcoming fewer Korean groups: 97, holding 9.7%, or 5.6% without the 3rd; comments regretting the reduction: 13, holding 0.1%. Comments discussing enka: 331, holding 8.2%. Comments on special slots announced later: 238, holding 7.3%. Comments asking for real singing rather than lip-sync: 77, holding 4.9%. Comments on the red and white team format: 73, holding 1.8%. Comments on the hosts: 44, holding 0.7%. I read the top 60 comments one by one and sorted the remaining 2,793 with the same table of headings, so the counts carry some margin. The comment my lady shared ranks 262nd in the thread, with 11 agree and 8 disagree presses.
Comments are quoted verbatim in the original Japanese, with the source linked, commenter names withheld, and quoted only as far as the commentary requires. Translations are mine. Source articles may expire (retrieval dates noted). The substance of this piece is the author's commentary.