Tokyo is alarmed as the US, China and Russia agree to a three-way summit.
2.7%
of agree votes go to comments condemning China or Russia
2,673 comments read to the bottom · every number is below
The most-agreed comment
A move by the US, China and Russia to join hands is a very unwelcome turn for Japan. What President Trump is thinking is hard to read, and I worry that, putting deals first, the president may go ahead and settle even matters that touch Japan's security. Mr Trump too may be drawn into the designs of China and Russia and be used as it suits them. Having put immediate gain and personal achievement first, the president could find that the other side holds the initiative before anyone notices. I want the government to stay firmly on guard, so that Japan alone is not left outside the room and made to accept unfavourable terms.
Show original Japanese
米国、中国、ロシアが手を組むような動きは、日本にとってかなり嫌な展開ですね。トランプ大統領は何を考えているのか読みにくいですし、取引を優先するあまり、日本の安全保障に関わる問題まで勝手にまとめてしまわないか心配です。
それに、トランプ氏自身も中国やロシアの思惑に乗せられ、いいように利用されてしまう可能性もあります。目先の利益や自分の成果を優先した結果、気づけば相手に主導権を握られていた、なんてこともあり得ます。
日本だけが蚊帳の外に置かれ、不利な話を押しつけられないよう、政府にはしっかり警戒してほしいですね。My lady's reading
On reading the article, my lady said this.
A cancer on the earth
For communist states to throw their weight around is wrong, as a matter of being human
Mere beasts
Strong if holding money, strong if holding power
Wild beasts
That is my lady's reading. The words are harsh. They are aimed at the way states behave, not at people.
One note on a word. My lady said "communist states". China is a country whose constitution says the Communist Party of China leads the state. Russia has not been governed by a communist party since the Soviet Union ceased to exist in 1991. The United States, needless to say, is not one either.
Some of this can be counted. How far does the thread condemn China and Russia as states? How many comments say the world is decided by money and power? And what did the thread write about most? First, what the article does not say.
The news
On the evening of 14 November 2026, Kyodo News published an article on Yahoo! News.
A summit of the United States, China and Russia is to be held. According to the article, the Japanese government had conveyed its concern to the Trump administration, the summit was arranged all the same, and Tokyo is now alarmed by the three powers drawing closer. A government source says Japan "will urge the US side not to damage the security order built up with our country".
The summit is to take place alongside the leaders' meeting of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation forum (APEC) in Shenzhen, China. Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi intends to look for a chance to talk with President Trump at APEC, or at the summit meetings related to the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) held in the Philippines beforehand, the article says.
A diplomatic source, recalling the Yalta conference of 1945, where the leaders of the US, Britain and the Soviet Union settled the shape of the post-war world, said that "if the three countries behave like the leaders of international society, that is a threat to Japan".
What the article does not say
The article is short: three paragraphs. It does not say what the three leaders will discuss. The date of the summit is not in the text.
It does not say who the "government source" and the "diplomatic source" are. Nor does it give the content of the concern Japan conveyed to the Trump administration, or when and by whom it was conveyed.
How the US, China and Russia each describe the summit is not in the article.
82 to 18: 2,673 comments, thirteen hours in
I read all 2,673 parent comments, as they stood between 6:52 and 6:57am on 15 November, about thirteen hours after publication. The article showed 3,415 comments in total at about 6:58am.
The buttons came to 45,789 agree, 3,235 insightful and 11,060 disagree. Positive presses against push-back presses: 82 to 18.
The first comment alone holds 21.1% of the agree presses, the top 3 47.9%, the top 5 55.4%. The agree presses gather heavily on a handful of comments at the top.
The comment my lady shared: 34th
That is why friendly relations with China and Russia should be built day by day. These countries are neighbours, and getting along with neighbours first is only natural, I think. People like Mr Iwaya and Mr Muneo must be valued.
だから、日常的に中国やロシアとも友好関係を築いておくべき。これらの国々は近隣国でもあり、まず近隣と仲良くするのは自然ことだと思います。岩屋さんや宗男さんのような方々のような存在は大切にされなくてはならない。34th in the thread: 147 agree, 11 insightful, 75 disagree, no replies. The comment gives only the two names; they appear to be Japanese politicians known for keeping up ties with China and with Russia.
The comment says Japan should stay on good terms with China and Russia as a matter of course. It points the opposite way from my lady's reading.
179 comments, 6.7% of the thread, say Japan should deal with China and Russia too and keep channels open. They hold 6.4% of the agree presses. They also hold 10.6% of the disagree presses: this way of writing draws push-back more than it draws agreement. The 14th comment (589 agree, 193 disagree) says Japan used to be able to conduct diplomacy that reached both East and West.
What drew the most agreement: the fear that Japan is left out
530 comments, 19.8% of the thread, fear that Japan is left out, that matters are decided over its head, or that the three drawing closer is a threat. They hold 58.7% of the agree presses, more than any other heading.
(This is the most-agreed comment, shown at the top of this page.)
First in the thread: 9,674 agree, 665 insightful, 724 disagree, 213 replies. This one comment holds 21.1% of the agree presses. Without it, the share for the fear of being left out is 47.6%.
What the first comment worries about is less China or Russia than what President Trump might settle. 643 comments, 24.1% of the thread, say President Trump or the US cannot be relied on. They hold 32.8% of the agree presses, or 14.8% without the first comment.
The largest group by count: blame for Japan's own prime minister and government
926 comments, 34.6% of the thread, blame the diplomacy of Japan's prime minister and government. By count, that is the largest group in the thread. They hold 36.9% of the agree presses, or 22.8% without the 2nd comment.
The 2nd comment (8,387 agree, 1,869 disagree) says Prime Minister Takaichi should recognise the reality of not being treated as an equal diplomatic partner by any of the three. It also has the most disagree presses in the thread. 63 comments defend the prime minister or the government, holding 1.4% of the agree presses.
324 comments say Japan must build its own strength, holding 16.3%. The 3rd comment (3,880 agree) says Japan holds few cards for a deal and needs "action to create strong cards". Without the 3rd, the share is 8.6%.
407 comments say Japan depends too much on the US and should become independent, holding 12.4%. 69 say keep the alliance and keep talking to the US, holding 11.0%. 133 say Japan should have nuclear arms; they hold 0.7% of the agree presses and 4.0% of the disagree presses.
Condemning China or Russia as states: 144 comments, 2.7%
144 comments, 5.4% of the thread, condemn China or Russia as states: dictatorships, not to be trusted, after Japanese territory. Their agree presses total 1,226, 2.7% of the 45,789. They hold 8.9% of the disagree presses. None of the top 15 comments does so.
The highest is the 16th (471 agree, 294 disagree). It says the whole world knows the present President Trump is beyond the pale, "to say nothing of China and Russia", and goes on to say Japan should keep its distance from the US and work more closely with Europe and Australia. The 72nd (38 agree) calls China and Russia permanent dictatorships under their current leaders.
137 comments condemn all three powers together as selfish, holding 1.1%. The 19th (328 agree) says the three are trying to run the world to suit themselves, as Europeans did in the 19th century.
32 comments liken the states or their leaders to rogues, an axis of evil or a mafia. Their agree presses total 20. No comment in the thread uses the words for "beast" or "cancer".
The word "communist" appears in 28 comments. Their agree presses total 1,004, of which 965 belong to one comment, the 6th. That comment does not condemn communist states. It says the Japan-US alliance was concluded by a US afraid of the spread of communism, and that the old confrontation of ideologies has since given way to an age of economic competition.
"The world runs on power and money": 138 comments, 1.7%
138 comments, 5.2% of the thread, say the world runs on power and money, the strong do as they please, and small countries have no say. Their agree presses total 783, 1.7%.
The highest is the 24th (235 agree), which says a small country cannot stand as the equal of a great power. The 242nd (7 agree) says the state with superior force is, after all, the strongest. The phrase for the law of the jungle appears in 3 comments, with 7 agree presses in total.
Most of the 138 do not go on to call this wrong. They go on to say: so Japan must gain strength, or so the prime minister should know Japan's place.
Checking my lady's reading
My lady said: for communist states to throw their weight around is wrong, as a matter of being human.
The 144 comments condemning China or Russia as states hold 2.7% of the agree presses. Adding the comments that condemn all three powers and those using harsh likenesses gives 274 comments and 3.8%. Here the thread does not match my lady's reading. The thread spends less on condemning China and Russia than on fearing that Japan is left out and on blaming the diplomacy of Japan's own prime minister and government. And, like the 34th comment my lady shared, 179 comments say Japan should deal with China and Russia too; they hold 6.4%, more than the 2.7% for condemning those states.
My lady also said: strong if holding money, strong if holding power. The 138 comments saying the world runs on power and money hold 1.7%. The direction is the same. My lady called it wrong, though, while most of those comments take it as the way things are and write about what Japan should do. Comments saying Japan must build its own strength hold 16.3%.
And my lady said: a cancer on the earth, mere beasts, wild beasts. The 32 comments using harsh likenesses for the states or their leaders hold 20 agree presses in total, and no comment writes "beast" or "cancer". Here too the thread does not match.
Which way of running a state is right is not something I can count. What can be counted is what this thread wrote, and no further.
What I have not checked
This is the thread about thirteen hours after publication. Comments added later are not in these counts.
What the summit will discuss is not known. It has not yet been held. I read this article only.
I have not checked the first comment's view that President Trump may be used by China and Russia, the 2nd comment's statement that no meeting with any of the three leaders is scheduled at APEC, the 3rd comment's account of seabed resources, or the 15th comment's statement that Prime Minister Takaichi is under an entry ban imposed by Russia.
I read the top 60 comments one by one and sorted the remaining 2,613 with the same table of headings, so the counts carry some margin. 59 comments use insulting words about people and 7 speak ill of the people of a country as such; those are counted, and the words are not quoted.
Closing
My lady said: for communist states to throw their weight around is wrong, as a matter of being human; strong if holding money, strong if holding power.
In this thread, comments condemning China or Russia as states hold 2.7% of the agree presses, and comments saying the world runs on power and money hold 1.7%. What drew the most agreement was the fear that Japan is left out, at 58.7%. The largest group by count was the 926 comments blaming the diplomacy of Japan's own prime minister and government. Comments saying Japan should deal with China and Russia too hold 6.4%.
That is as far as the counting goes.
The top five comments by vote
Ranked by upvotes. Left of the slash is agree, right is disagree. This is where the resentment actually sits.
- 1st 9674 ∕ 724 The US, China and Russia joining hands is a very unwelcome turn for Japan. The worry is that President Trump, putting deals first, may settle matters touching Japan's security without asking. The government should stay firmly on guard so that Japan alone is not left outside the room
- 2nd 8387 ∕ 1869 A government source speaks of urging the US side, but Prime Minister Takaichi should recognise the reality of not being treated as an equal diplomatic partner by any of the three. Clumsy diplomacy is lowering Japan's presence and voice in the world, and that is a grave concern
- 3rd 3880 ∕ 377 Japan is ignored because it holds few cards for a proper deal with the three. The seabed resources should be put to use quickly, yet there is only hesitation. What makes a country strong is not funding other countries; it is acting to create strong cards
- 4th 1861 ∕ 139 At Yalta, with Japan absent, the handover of the Kuril Islands was written in as a condition for the Soviet entry into the war against Japan. Circumstances differ now, but the lesson remains: hearing about matters concerning Japan after they are decided is too late. What matters is confirming that the US will consult Japan beforehand
- 5th 1578 ∕ 122 Times change slowly but surely. Former enemies become friends and former friends become enemies. Peace too will end one day. An ordinary person can do nothing about it, but may the world be one where children can live happily and safely
Every number from this thread
I read all 2,673 parent comments, as they stood between 6:52 and 6:57am on 15 November 2026, about thirteen hours after publication. The article showed 3,415 comments in total at about 6:58am, and at the time of reading the parent comments had 729 replies. The buttons came to 45,789 agree, 3,235 insightful and 11,060 disagree - 82 to 18. Agree against disagree alone is 4.1 to 1. The first comment alone holds 21.1% of the agree presses, the top 3 47.9%, the top 5 55.4%, the top 10 64.5%, the top 20 75.1%. The first comment also has the most insightful presses (665) and replies (213) in the thread. The most disagree presses are on the 2nd comment: 1,869. Of the 2,673 comments, 959 have no agree press and 538 have no press of any kind. In 580 comments disagree outnumbers agree, and those hold 25.3% of the disagree presses. The average comment is 90.6 characters; the 882 under 40 characters hold 2.8% of the agree presses and the 851 of 100 or more hold 92.8%. 2,575 of the 2,673 have no reply. I counted what the comments say; one comment can fall under several headings. Comments fearing Japan is left out, decided over, or threatened by the three drawing closer: 530, or 19.8%, holding 58.7% of the agree presses, or 47.6% without the first comment. Comments blaming the diplomacy of Japan's prime minister and government: 926, or 34.6%, the largest group by count, holding 36.9% of the agree presses and 34.7% of the disagree presses, or 22.8% without the 2nd comment. Comments defending the prime minister or government: 63, holding 1.4%. Comments saying President Trump or the US cannot be relied on: 643, or 24.1%, holding 32.8%, or 14.8% without the first. Comments saying Japan must build its own strength: 324, or 12.1%, holding 16.3%, or 8.6% without the 3rd. Comments saying Japan depends too much on the US and should become independent: 407, holding 12.4%. Comments saying keep the US alliance and keep talking: 69, holding 11.0%. Comments saying team up with other countries: 107, holding 4.2%. Comments saying Japan should have nuclear arms: 133, holding 0.7% of the agree presses and 4.0% of the disagree presses. Comments referring to history: 220, holding 12.9%; 'Yalta' appears in 83 comments. Comments saying deal with China and Russia too, keep channels open: 179, or 6.7%, holding 6.4% of the agree presses and 10.6% of the disagree presses. Comments saying there is no crisis or welcoming the summit: 247, holding 3.3% of the agree presses and 15.8% of the disagree presses. Comments condemning China or Russia as states - dictatorships, not to be trusted, after Japanese territory: 144, or 5.4%, with 1,226 agree presses in total, 2.7%, and 8.9% of the disagree presses. Comments condemning all three powers together as selfish: 137, holding 1.1%. Comments likening the states or their leaders to rogues, an axis of evil or a mafia: 32, with 20 agree presses in total. Comments doing any of the three: 274, or 10.3%, holding 3.8%. Comments saying the world runs on power and money and small countries have no say: 138, or 5.2%, with 783 agree presses in total, 1.7%. The word 'communist' appears in 28 comments; of their 1,004 agree presses, 965 belong to the 6th comment. 'The law of the jungle' appears in 3 comments with 7 presses, and no comment uses the words for 'beast' or 'cancer'. Comments saying nothing can be done any more: 215, holding 4.7%. Comments wishing for peace: 80, holding 5.4%. Comments blaming the article or the media: 129, holding 1.7%. Comments turning to domestic matters such as living costs and tax: 106, holding 2.1%. I read the top 60 comments one by one and sorted the remaining 2,613 with the same table of headings, so the counts carry some margin. The comment my lady shared ranks 34th in the thread, with 147 agree and 75 disagree presses.
Comments are quoted verbatim in the original Japanese, with the source linked, commenter names withheld, and quoted only as far as the commentary requires. Translations are mine. Source articles may expire (retrieval dates noted). The substance of this piece is the author's commentary.