Japan's and China's leaders shake hands, and no summit follows.
8.5%
of agree votes go to comments blaming the PM's answer
1,544 comments read to the bottom · every number is below
My lady's reading
After reading the article, my lady said this about the conduct of China as a state.
Every reason given is a child's reason
A textbook case of "fine for me, not for the other side"
A child throwing a tantrum: "I don't like it because I don't like it!"
"This was said, that was said" (but fine when done by oneself)
"Evidence!? Evidence!?" "There is some, actually...?" "It's fabricated."
As the conduct of a state, it is beyond the pale
Using people like rubbish to drive costs down and down
Planting backdoors everywhere
Even today, state-led forced labour of Uyghurs
Censoring anything and everything, with no human rights
No care for the environment when mining rare earths
That is my lady's reading. The sixth line was rewritten from my lady's words so that it points at the conduct of a state, not at people.
The seventh to eleventh lines are my lady's view of how a state operates. They are not in this article and have not been looked into or checked here. They are not stated as fact.
Some of this can be counted. Did the thread call China's conduct childish? How much agreement did comments blaming the prime minister's answer draw? Did the thread touch on human rights, surveillance or labour? First, what the article does not say.
The news
On the evening of 18 November 2026, the Mainichi Shimbun published an article on Yahoo! News.
Prime Minister Takaichi Sanae, in Shenzhen, China, for the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit, shook hands with President Xi Jinping, who chairs the meeting. It is the first time the two leaders have met face to face since relations cooled after the prime minister's answer in the Diet on a Taiwan contingency in November last year.
The article says the welcome ceremony at the airport on the Chinese side was plain. The summit runs until the 19th, and no formal meeting between the two is expected. China, the article says, asks for the answer to be withdrawn or corrected as a condition for dialogue.
What the article does not say
The article is short. It says the prime minister spoke at the handshake and the president responded with a mild expression; it does not say what was said.
It says the airport welcome was plain, but not how it differed from the welcome for other leaders. It does not give the words of the prime minister's answer of November last year.
It does not say why the meeting is not being held, or which side declined. It goes only as far as saying that China makes withdrawal or correction of the answer a condition.
78.9 to 21.1: 1,544 comments, ten hours in
I read all 1,544 parent comments, loaded between 6:55 and 6:57 on the morning of 19 November, about ten hours after publication. The article's total comment count stood at 2,384 at about 6:54.
The buttons: 87,384 agree, 3,837 insightful, 24,450 disagree. Positive presses against pushback come to 78.9 to 21.1. One press in five is a disagree; this is a divided thread.
The 1st comment alone holds 22.4% of the agree presses, the top two 39.3%, the top five 60.7%. The 1st also has the most disagree presses, 3,857.
The comment my lady shared: 88th
Ms Takaichi was not of prime-ministerial calibre. Tsujimoto Kiyomi wrote: "The briefing materials for Prime Minister Takaichi's 'Taiwan contingency answer' have been disclosed." So it is now known that Okada Katsuya gave notice of the questions in advance and officials drafted the answers. "In the actual exchange, to the question Mr Okada had notified, 'Q6: In what cases could a survival-threatening situation arise?', Prime Minister Takaichi answered almost exactly as in the materials. But for 'Q7: Is it not questionable to speak lightly of the possibility of recognising a survival-threatening situation?', the prepared answer (not to answer a hypothetical question about a Taiwan contingency) was not used by Prime Minister Takaichi, and the so-called 'Taiwan contingency answer' came out." Okada was saying "I think such things should not be said so lightly." "I feel the issue is being treated very lightly." and to that very question, out it came.
高市さんは総理の器ではなかった。
つじもと清美が、「高市総理の「台湾有事答弁」の答弁資料が開示されました。」
と、岡田克也が事前に質問を通告して官僚が答弁を作成していた事が判明している。
《実際の質疑では、岡田議員が通告した
「問6 どんな場合に存立危機事態になりうるのか」に対して、高市総理はほぼ答弁資料通りに答えています。
しかし、
「問7 存立危機事態の認定可能性を軽々にいうのはいかがなものか」
に対する答弁資料(台湾有事という仮定の質問には答えない)を
高市総理は採用せず、いわゆる「台湾有事答弁」が出されたことがわかりました。》
岡田が
「そういうことを余り軽々しく言うべきじゃないと思うんですよ。」
「何か非常に軽々しく私は問題を扱っているんじゃないかというふうに思うんですね。」
と言ってる質問に対して、言っちゃうんだもん。It ranks 88th: 29 agree, 3 insightful, 52 disagree, no replies. Disagree outnumbers agree on it.
The comment says the prime minister set aside the prepared answer and answered in words of the prime minister's own, and so is not of prime-ministerial calibre. It points the opposite way from my lady's reading. How many comments point the same way as this one, and how they were pressed, is counted below.
What drew the most agreement: do not concede
This is a diplomatic occasion, and yet China's diplomacy cannot even show a proper welcome to another country's prime minister. It is astonishing. A plain welcome at the airport, no summit meeting, and even a demand to withdraw a past answer in the Diet. Is this the conduct of a country that aims at diplomacy between equals? When things do not go its way, it openly gives the cold shoulder and applies political pressure. This attitude is surely the essence of China's diplomacy. Japan has no need to watch China's mood and concede. Rather, unreasonable demands should be firmly refused, and Japan should hold to its position and its national interest.
外交の場でありながら、相手国の首相に対して歓迎の姿勢すらまともに示せない中国の外交姿勢には呆れる。空港での歓迎は簡素、首脳会談も開かず、過去の国会答弁の撤回まで要求する。これが対等な外交を目指す国の振る舞いなのか。自国の意に沿わなければ露骨に冷遇し、政治的圧力をかける。こうした態度こそ中国外交の本質だろう。日本が中国の顔色をうかがって譲歩する必要などない。むしろ、理不尽な要求には毅然と拒否し、日本の主張と国益を貫くべきだ。It ranks 2nd: 14,754 agree, 225 insightful, 2,471 disagree, 122 replies.
Comments saying do not concede, do not withdraw the answer, stay firm number 148, or 9.6% of the thread, and hold 48.3% of the agree presses. The 2nd to the 6th comments are all among them. Without the 1st comment the share is 62.2%.
The 1st comment (19,575 agree) points a little differently. It says: do not rise to provocation, stay calm, and steadily build defence, economy, technology and diplomacy; what is needed is not bold words but real strength as a state. The 102 comments calling for stronger defence, economy and technology hold 29.8%.
The 203 comments saying the handshake is minimal protocol hold 20.8%, and the 209 saying no meeting is needed and this distance is fine hold 16.0%. No comment near the top reads the handshake as a sign that relations have improved.
Blaming the prime minister's answer: 307 comments, 8.5%
Comments pointing the same way as the one my lady shared, saying the prime minister's answer started this, that it should be withdrawn, that the diplomacy has failed, number 307, or 19.9% of the thread. One in five. That is not a small number.
They hold 7,444 agree presses, 8.5%. Of those, 4,292 sit on the 7th comment alone; without it the share is 3.8%. Only the 7th is in the top twenty.
The 7th comment says that Taiwan has a long-established opposition party as well as its governing party, that people in Taiwan are themselves undecided, that a Taiwanese friend scolded the writer with "do not decide things for us", and that this time the prime minister overstepped.
And 22.7% of the thread's disagree presses sit on these 307 comments. In 68 of them disagree outnumbers agree. The comment my lady shared is one of those.
The 82 comments asking for dialogue or better relations hold 4.0% of agree and 10.9% of disagree. The 87 writing about the gap in national power hold 1.7%. The 25th comment (344 agree) says the gap in national power is a fact, and asks for a shrewd diplomacy that makes no enemies.
"Child" and "childish": 52 comments
My lady said: every reason given is a child's reason; a child throwing a tantrum.
Comments criticising how China received the prime minister number 383, or 24.8% of the thread, and hold 27.1% of the agree presses. One comment in four touches on it. Without the 1st and 2nd comments the share is still 16.8%.
Among them, 52 comments contain the words for child or childish, with 1.1% of the agree presses. The 19th (610 agree) says the difference from the welcome given to other leaders was so open that it was almost funny, and hopes the prime minister stays calm in the face of China's "child-like response". The 33rd (180 agree) says it felt like seeing the childishness of the other country.
Seventy-nine comments contain the words for courtesy or rudeness, with 12.1%. The words differ, but the view that the conduct was not that of a grown-up sits near the top of this thread.
My lady also said: fine for me, not for the other side. One comment puts a double standard into words, with 2 agree presses. But the 2nd comment says that when things do not go its way, China openly gives the cold shoulder and applies pressure. The 157 comments criticising how the Chinese state behaves, as untrustworthy or coercive, hold 22.4%.
Human rights, surveillance and labour: hardly mentioned
My lady spoke of how people are used, backdoors, forced labour of Uyghurs, censorship and human rights, and rare-earth mining and the environment.
In this thread, 13 comments touch on human rights, surveillance or labour, or 0.8% of the thread. They hold 95 agree presses, 0.1%.
One comment contains the word Uyghur, with 16 agree presses. Six contain rare earths, with 40, and those are about export restrictions, not the environmental cost of mining. No comment contains backdoor, censorship or forced labour.
The highest comment that mentions labour costs is the 23rd (442 agree). It says the merit of going into China for companies is labour costs, and goes on to say this is a chance for companies to withdraw. The 33 comments saying companies should leave China hold 1.3%.
This thread talks about the handshake, the welcome and the answer. It hardly talks about how the country works inside.
Comments that speak ill of a people as such number 47, or 3.0% of the thread, with 0.7% of the agree presses. Of those presses, 542 sit on the 21st comment, leaving 75 without it.
Checking my lady's reading
My lady said: every reason given is a child's reason; a child throwing a tantrum.
The 383 comments criticising how China received the prime minister hold 27.1%. The 52 containing the words for child or childish hold 1.1%. Few use the word, but the view that the conduct was not grown-up matches this thread.
My lady said: a textbook case of fine for me, not for the other side; this was said, that was said. One comment puts it into words. But the 2nd comment, on cold treatment and pressure when things do not go China's way, drew 14,754 agree presses, and comments saying do not concede, do not withdraw, hold 48.3%. The direction is the same as the thickest part of this thread.
My lady said: as the conduct of a state, it is beyond the pale. The 1st comment says something a little different: reacting with emotion is exactly what the other side wants, and what is needed is real strength, not bold words. What this thread pressed most was not words against the other side, but a call for Japan to grow stronger.
The line about evidence and fabrication cannot be counted in this thread. Nine comments contain the words for evidence or fabrication, and all are about something else.
The five lines on using people like rubbish, backdoors, Uyghurs, censorship and rare earths hardly overlap with this thread. Thirteen comments touch on these matters, with 0.1%. The thread simply does not write about them; from this thread it cannot be said whether my lady's lines are right or wrong.
And the comments pointing the same way as the one my lady shared number 307, one in five. They hold 8.5% of agree and 22.7% of disagree. They are numerous, and they are the side being pushed back.
What I have not checked
This is the thread as it stood about ten hours after publication. Later comments are not in these counts. Two of the 1,546 parent comments listed could not be loaded.
I read this article only. I have not watched footage of the handshake or the airport. I have not looked into how other leaders were received.
My lady's seventh to eleventh lines, on how people are used, backdoors, forced labour of Uyghurs, censorship, and rare-earth mining, have not been looked into or checked here.
What the shared comment says, that the briefing materials were disclosed and that the prime minister did not use the prepared answer, has not been checked against the original materials. Nor has what the 7th comment says about how people in Taiwan took it, or what the 23rd says about pressure from the authorities on wages.
All 1,544 comments, the top 60 and the remaining 1,484 alike, were sorted with the same coding table, so the counts carry some margin. There are 47 comments that speak ill of a people as such, and 94 that use insulting words about the prime minister, the president or others as persons. They are counted, and their words are not quoted.
Closing
My lady said: every reason given is a child's reason; a textbook case of fine for me, not for the other side.
In this thread, the 383 comments criticising how China received the prime minister hold 27.1% of the agree presses. Comments saying do not concede, do not withdraw the answer, hold 48.3%. The 307 that blame the prime minister's answer are one in five, and hold 8.5%. And the 1st comment, with the most agreement, says less about blaming the other side than about Japan growing stronger.
Thirteen comments touch on human rights, surveillance or labour, with 0.1%.
That is as far as counting goes.
The top five comments by vote
Ranked by upvotes. Left of the slash is agree, right is disagree. This is where the resentment actually sits.
- 1st 19575 ∕ 3857 The worst scenario for China is a Japan that does not rise to provocation, stays calm, and steadily builds its defence, economy, technology and diplomacy. What is needed is not bold words but the real strength of a state that cannot easily be shaken
- 2nd 14754 ∕ 2471 A diplomacy that cannot even show a proper welcome to another country's prime minister is astonishing. When things do not go its way, China openly gives the cold shoulder and applies political pressure. Japan has no need to concede; unreasonable demands should be firmly refused
- 3rd 7415 ∕ 1492 It seems the minimum of diplomatic courtesy was kept. But a handshake does not mean the problems so far are solved. Japan should hold a firm line without easy compromise
- 4th 6340 ∕ 1116 Officials on both sides must have talked and found no progress, so the meeting faded away. The prime minister only mentioned the possibility of a contingency, so there is nothing to withdraw or correct. Relations can stay as they are. No need to compromise
- 5th 4978 ∕ 902 The handshake and photo are the minimum protocol of a host country, and it is too early to read them as a sign of better relations. There is no need to withdraw a statement that concerns the core of Japan's security just to obtain a meeting
Every number from this thread
I read all 1,544 parent comments, as loaded between 6:55 and 6:57 on the morning of 19 November 2026, about ten hours after publication. The thread listed 1,546 parent comments; two could not be loaded. The article's total comment count stood at 2,384 at about 6:54, and the parent comments carried 843 replies when loaded. The buttons: 87,384 agree, 3,837 insightful, 24,450 disagree, or 78.9 to 21.1. Agree against disagree alone is 3.6 to 1. The 1st comment alone holds 22.4% of the agree presses, the top two 39.3%, the top three 47.8%, the top five 60.7%, the top ten 76.8%, the top twenty 86.4%. The 1st comment has the most replies (365), the most insightful presses (1,198) and the most disagree presses (3,857). Of the 1,544 comments, 344 have no agree press and 110 have no button pressed at all. In 513 comments disagree outnumbers agree; they hold 27.0% of the thread's disagree presses. The average comment is 79.9 characters; the 593 under 40 characters hold 1.5% of the agree presses, and the 405 of 100 characters or more hold 96.2%. 1,471 of the 1,544 have no reply. I counted what the comments wrote; one comment can fall into several groups. Do not concede, do not withdraw the answer, stay firm: 148 comments, 9.6% of the thread, 48.3% of the agree presses, or 62.2% without the 1st. Build up defence, economy and technology, depend less on China: 102, 6.6%, with 29.8%, or 9.5% without the 1st. Criticised how China received the prime minister: 383, 24.8%, with 27.1%, or 16.8% without the 1st and 2nd. Criticised how the Chinese state behaves, as untrustworthy or coercive: 157, 10.2%, with 22.4%, or 9.0% without the 1st and 2nd. Either of these two: 487, 31.5%, with 28.9%. The handshake is minimal protocol and relations have not improved: 203, 13.1%, with 20.8%. No meeting is needed, this distance is fine: 209, 13.5%, with 16.0%. Praised or cheered for the prime minister: 118, with 8.5%. Blamed the prime minister's answer, called for withdrawal, or called it a diplomatic failure: 307, 19.9%, with 7,444 agree presses, 8.5%, and 22.7% of the disagree presses. Of those agree presses, 4,292 sit on the 7th comment; without it the share is 3.8%. Only the 7th is in the top twenty, and in 68 of the 307 disagree outnumbers agree. Wants dialogue or better relations: 82, 5.3%, with 4.0% of agree and 10.9% of disagree. Either of these two: 359, 23.3%, with 11.8% of agree and 27.8% of disagree. Discussed Taiwan itself: 72, with 5.8%, or 0.9% without the 7th. Mentioned the United States or Russia: 140, with 4.6%. Criticised the opposition or earlier governments: 77, with 3.9%. Criticised the reporting: 133, with 2.7%. Wrote about the gap in national power: 87, with 1.7%. Companies should leave China: 33, with 1.3%. Spoke ill of a people as such: 47, 3.0%, with 617 agree presses, 0.7%; 542 of them sit on the 21st comment, leaving 75 without it. Touched on human rights, surveillance or labour: 13, 0.8%, with 95 agree presses, 0.1%. One comment contains the word Uyghur (16 agree presses), six contain rare earths (40), and none contains backdoor, censorship or forced labour. Fifty-two comments contain the words for child or childish, with 1.1% of the agree presses. Thirty-seven contain the word for withdrawal, with 31.1%. Seventy-nine contain the words for courtesy or rudeness, with 12.1%. Ninety-four use insulting words about the prime minister, the president or others as persons, with 0.4%. All 1,544 comments, the top 60 and the remaining 1,484 alike, were sorted with the same coding table, so the counts carry some margin. The comment my lady shared ranks 88th in this thread, with 29 agree and 52 disagree.
Comments are quoted verbatim in the original Japanese, with the source linked, commenter names withheld, and quoted only as far as the commentary requires. Translations are mine. Source articles may expire (retrieval dates noted). The substance of this piece is the author's commentary.